Completely greedy coin sets

Andrew J. Young
2024-07-27
Abstract:We show that the binary coin set minimizes the number of coins needed to guarantee the ability to make change in any one transaction and its asymptotic uniform average cost is no worse than that of any completely greedy coin set.
Combinatorics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the optimal configuration of coin sets in the change-making problem and introduces a new concept—completely greedy coin sets. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following core issues: 1. **Minimum Number of Coins**: The study investigates the minimum number of coins required to guarantee change in any single transaction. The paper proves that for any given maximum transaction value \( N \), the size of the optimal coin set is at least \( \lceil \log_2(N+1) \rceil \). 2. **Definition and Characteristics of Complete Greediness**: A coin set is defined as completely greedy if all its subsets are greedy. The paper proves that binary coin sets (i.e., sets like {1, 2, 4, 8, ...}) possess complete greediness and uniqueness, and are optimal in a certain sense. 3. **Theoretical Results**: Through a series of theorems and corollaries, the paper demonstrates some important properties of completely greedy coin sets, such as their size not exceeding the logarithmic level of \( \log_2(N) \) and their good performance in an asymptotic sense. 4. **Asymptotic Analysis**: The paper also discusses the asymptotic behavior of infinite completely greedy coin sets and provides an asymptotic expression for their cost function. Specifically, for an infinite completely greedy coin set \( C \), the upper limit of the cost function \( \text{cost}(N; C) \) as \( N \) approaches infinity is \( \frac{1}{2} \). Through these studies, the paper aims to solve the optimal coin configuration problem in the change-making problem and provides a theoretical foundation for practical applications.