Promoting AI Competencies for Medical Students: A Scoping Review on Frameworks, Programs, and Tools

Yingbo Ma,Yukyeong Song,Jeremy A. Balch,Yuanfang Ren,Divya Vellanki,Zhenhong Hu,Meghan Brennan,Suraj Kolla,Ziyuan Guan,Brooke Armfield,Tezcan Ozrazgat-Baslanti,Parisa Rashidi,Tyler J. Loftus,Azra Bihorac,Benjamin Shickel

2024-07-11

Abstract:As more clinical workflows continue to be augmented by artificial intelligence (AI), AI literacy among physicians will become a critical requirement for ensuring safe and ethical AI-enabled patient care. Despite the evolving importance of AI in healthcare, the extent to which it has been adopted into traditional and often-overloaded medical curricula is currently unknown. In a scoping review of 1,699 articles published between January 2016 and June 2024, we identified 18 studies which propose guiding frameworks, and 11 studies documenting real-world instruction, centered around the integration of AI into medical education. We found that comprehensive guidelines will require greater clinical relevance and personalization to suit medical student interests and career trajectories. Current efforts highlight discrepancies in the teaching guidelines, emphasizing AI evaluation and ethics over technical topics such as data science and coding. Additionally, we identified several challenges associated with integrating AI training into the medical education program, including a lack of guidelines to define medical students AI literacy, a perceived lack of proven clinical value, and a scarcity of qualified instructors. With this knowledge, we propose an AI literacy framework to define competencies for medical students. To prioritize relevant and personalized AI education, we categorize literacy into four dimensions: Foundational, Practical, Experimental, and Ethical, with tailored learning objectives to the pre-clinical, clinical, and clinical research stages of medical education. This review provides a road map for developing practical and relevant education strategies for building an AI-competent healthcare workforce.

Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how to better integrate artificial intelligence (AI) teaching content into medical education to cultivate the skills and knowledge future doctors will need in an increasingly AI-driven healthcare environment.

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Address

1. **Theoretical Framework and Guidelines**: Identify existing theoretical proposals and guidelines to define the AI literacy that medical students should possess. This includes understanding the basics of AI, the ability to apply AI, the ability to evaluate and create AI tools, and understanding AI ethics.

2. **Practical Teaching Methods**: Summarize the current teaching methods used to impart AI knowledge to medical students, including formal courses, extracurricular projects, or workshops. The study focuses on the structure of these programs, teaching materials, covered topics, teachers' professional backgrounds, educational tools used, evaluation methods, main findings and outcomes, and limitations.

3. **Gap Between Theory and Practice**: Identify inconsistencies between existing theoretical guidelines and actual teaching practices.

4. **Challenges Faced**: Identify difficulties encountered when integrating AI training into the medical education system, such as the lack of clear standards defining AI literacy for medical students, insufficient awareness of AI's clinical value, and a shortage of qualified instructors.

5. **Lack of Personalized Educational Tools**: Point out the current lack of customized educational tools for medical students.

6. **Future Opportunities**: Provide directions for researchers and educators to develop more flexible, engaging, and personalized AI learning experiences to meet the needs of future doctors.

Through the above analysis, the paper aims to provide a practical and relevant educational strategy blueprint for building a healthcare workforce equipped with AI capabilities.