Pedro Royo,Elkin Muñoz,José-Enrique Romero,José-Vicente Manjón,Catalina Roig,Carmen Fernández-Delgado,Nuria Muñiz,Antonio Requena,Nicolás Garrido,Juan Antonio García- Velasco,Antonio Pellicer
Abstract:Ultrasound follicle tracking is an important part of cycle monitoring. OSIS Ovary (Online System for Image Segmentation for the Ovary) has been conceived aiming to aid the management of the workflow in follicle tracking, one of the most iterative procedures in cycle monitoring during ovarian stimulation. In the present study, we compared OSIS Ovary (as three-dimensional ultrasound-based automated system) with the two-dimensional manual standard measurement method, in order to assess the reliability of the main measurements obtained to track follicle growth during ovarian stimulation cycles, the follicle size and count. Based on the mean follicle diameter and follicle count values obtained, the Pearson/intraclass correlation coefficients were 0.976/0.987 and 0.804/0.889 in >=10mm follicles, 0.989/0.994 and 0.809/0.867 in >=13mm follicles and 0.995/0.997 and 0.791/0.840 in >=16mm follicles. The mean difference (MnD) for the mean diameter and follicle count was, respectively, 0.759/0.161 in >=10mm follicles, 0.486/1.033 in >=13mm follicles and 0.784/0.486 in >=16mm follicles. The upper and lower limits of agreement (ULA and LLA) were 3.641/2.123 and 5.392/3.070 in >=10mm follicles, 3.496/2.522 and 4.285/2.218 in >=13mm follicles, and 3.723/2.153 and 2.432/1.459 in >=16mm follicles. The limits of agreement range (LoAR) were 5.764/8.462 in >=10mm follicles, 6.048/6.503 in >=13mm follicles and 5.876/3.891 in >=16mm follicles. P<0.05 was considered for all calculations. As three-dimensional ultrasound-based automated system in comparison with two-dimensional manual method standard, we found OSIS Ovary as a reliable tool to track follicle growth during ovarian stimulation cycles
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in the ovarian stimulation cycle, by using an automated system based on three - dimensional ultrasound (OSIS Ovary) to automatically measure the size and number of ovarian follicles, in order to improve the efficiency and accuracy of follicle tracking. Specifically, the main purpose of the study is to compare the OSIS Ovary system with the traditional two - dimensional manual ultrasound measurement method and evaluate its reliability and consistency in monitoring the follicle growth process.
### Research Background
In assisted reproductive technologies (such as in vitro fertilization, IVF), follicle tracking is an important part of cycle monitoring. Although the traditional manual measurement method is widely used, it may become cumbersome, inaccurate when dealing with a large number of follicles, and may affect clinical results. To overcome these limitations, researchers have developed the OSIS Ovary system, aiming to simplify and optimize the follicle tracking process by automated means.
### Research Objectives
1. **Compare the two measurement methods**: Compare the OSIS Ovary system with the traditional two - dimensional manual ultrasound measurement method and evaluate its measurement reliability for different follicle sizes (≥10mm, ≥13mm, ≥16mm).
2. **Verify the accuracy of the automated system**: Through statistical analysis (such as Pearson correlation coefficient, intra - class correlation coefficient, Bland - Altman plot, etc.), verify the accuracy of the OSIS Ovary system in measuring follicle diameter and number.
### Main Conclusions
The study shows that the OSIS Ovary system exhibits a high degree of reliability and consistency in measuring follicle diameter and number, especially in different follicle growth stages (≥10mm, ≥13mm, ≥16mm). Specific indicators are as follows:
- **Pearson correlation coefficient (r)** and **intra - class correlation coefficient (ICC)**:
- For ≥10mm follicles: \(r = 0.976\), \(ICC = 0.987\)
- For ≥13mm follicles: \(r = 0.989\), \(ICC = 0.994\)
- For ≥16mm follicles: \(r = 0.995\), \(ICC = 0.997\)
- **Mean difference (MnD)** and **limits of agreement (LoAR)**:
- For ≥10mm follicles: MnD = 0.759, LoAR = 5.764
- For ≥13mm follicles: MnD = 0.486, LoAR = 6.048
- For ≥16mm follicles: MnD = 0.784, LoAR = 5.876
These results indicate that the OSIS Ovary system can be used as a reliable tool for follicle tracking in the ovarian stimulation cycle and is expected to be further applied in clinical practice in the future.
### Future Prospects
Researchers plan to conduct further in - depth studies in different clinical scenarios to optimize and evaluate the performance of the OSIS Ovary system, so that it can be more widely used in daily clinical practice, thereby simplifying and improving the efficiency and accuracy of follicle tracking.