Tipping detection using climate networks

Laure Moinat,Jérôme Kasparian,Maura Brunetti
2024-07-26
Abstract:The development of robust Early Warning Signals (EWS) is necessary to quantify the risk of crossing tipping points in the present-day climate change. Classically, EWS are statistical measures based on time series of climate state variables, without exploiting their spatial distribution. However, spatial information is crucial to identify the starting location of a transition process, and can be directly inferred by satellite observations. By using complex networks constructed from several climate variables on the numerical grid of climate simulations, we seek for network properties that can serve as EWS when approaching a state transition. We show that network indicators such as the normalized degree, the average length distance and the betweenness centrality are capable of detecting tipping points at the global scale, as obtained by the MIT general circulation model in a coupled-aquaplanet configuration for CO$_2$ concentration-driven simulations. The applicability of such indicators as EWS is assessed and compared to traditional methods. We also analyse the ability of climate networks to identify nonlinear dynamical patterns.
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics,Chaotic Dynamics,Geophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of how to detect the arrival of tipping points using climate networks in the context of current climate change. Specifically: 1. **Limitations of traditional early warning signals (EWS)**: Traditional EWS are based on time series analysis but ignore spatial distribution information. However, spatial information is crucial for identifying the starting location of the transition process and can be directly obtained through satellite observations. 2. **New method combining spatiotemporal information**: By gridding the Earth's surface and constructing complex networks, researchers hope to use these network properties as EWS to detect the system's approach to state transitions. They demonstrate that network metrics such as normalized degree, average path length, and betweenness centrality can detect tipping points on a global scale. 3. **Simulation and experimental validation**: The study uses the MIT General Circulation Model in a coupled aquaplanet configuration driven by CO2 concentration to evaluate the effectiveness of these metrics as EWS and compare them with traditional methods. Additionally, the ability of climate networks to identify nonlinear dynamical patterns is analyzed. 4. **Specific applications**: The research explores the performance of climate networks during global-scale transitions from cold state to hot state (C-H) and from cold state to snowball state (C-S), and the impact of these transitions on network structure. By varying different parameters such as the size of the time window and the discretization level of the forcing rate, the robustness and applicability of the method are validated.