Abstract:In social decision-making among strategic agents, a universal focus lies on the balance between social and individual interests. Socially efficient mechanisms are thus desirably designed to not only maximize the social welfare but also incentivize the agents for their own profit. Under a generalized model that includes applications such as double auctions and trading networks, this study establishes a socially efficient (SE), dominant-strategy incentive compatible (DSIC), and individually rational (IR) mechanism with the minimum total budget expensed to the agents. The present method exploits discrete and known type domains to reduce a set of constraints into the shortest path problem in a weighted graph. In addition to theoretical derivation, we substantiate the optimality of the proposed mechanism through numerical experiments, where it certifies strictly lower budget than Vickery-Clarke-Groves (VCG) mechanisms for a wide class of instances.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve
This paper aims to solve how to design a mechanism in social decision - making to achieve social efficiency (SE), dominant - strategy incentive compatibility (DSIC) and individual rationality (IR) with the minimum total budget. Specifically, the research objectives are:
1. **Maximize social welfare**: Ensure that the selected decision is most beneficial to the whole society.
2. **Incentivize individual participation**: Through payment or collection of fees, make each participant motivated to truthfully report their type, thus promoting social welfare.
3. **Ensure individual rationality**: Ensure that each participant will not suffer losses due to participation.
4. **Minimize the total budget**: Under the premise of meeting the above three conditions, try to reduce the total cost paid by the broker as much as possible.
### Research background and problem description
In the social decision - making process involving multiple self - interested agents, a common focus is how to balance social and individual interests. To this end, it is necessary to design a mechanism that can both maximize social welfare and motivate agents to pursue their own interests. However, previous research has shown that in some cases, in order to simultaneously achieve SE, DSIC and IR, there must be a budget contribution from the broker. Therefore, the broker needs to minimize the budget while achieving these properties, or maximize revenue without a positive budget.
### Main contributions
The main contribution of this paper is to propose a novel algorithm that can find the budget - optimal solution among all mechanisms that satisfy the SE, DSIC and IR properties. The key idea of this method is to use the discrete and known type domains of agents to transform the constraint conditions into the shortest - path problem in a weighted graph. Unlike most related work, the proposed mechanism does not belong to the well - known VCG mechanism class, but shows better results than the best VCG mechanism in numerical experiments.
### Specific problem description
The paper solves the problem in the following ways:
- **Define the environment and mechanism**: Formally define the environment including the agent group, option set and type domain, and on this basis, define the mechanism and its properties.
- **VCG mechanism analysis**: Review and analyze the classic VCG mechanism as a benchmark for comparison.
- **New mechanism design**: Propose a new mechanism, determine the payment rule by constructing a weighted graph and solving the shortest - path problem, so as to minimize the budget.
- **Theoretical proof and numerical experiment**: Theoretically prove the optimality of the new mechanism, and verify through numerical experiments that its performance is better than that of the VCG mechanism.
### Conclusion
This research successfully identifies and proposes a mechanism that is budget - optimal among all mechanisms that satisfy the SE, DSIC and IR properties. It is further confirmed by numerical experiments that the budget required by this mechanism is strictly lower than that of any VCG mechanism in most cases. Future research can focus on expanding this method to continuous or unknown type domains.
---
Hope this summary can help you understand the core problems and solutions of this paper. If you have any further questions or need more detailed information, please feel free to let us know!