Abstract:In this paper, we introduce the third party to achieve the Stackelberg equilibrium with the time inconsistency in three different Stackelberg games, which are the discrete-time games, the dynamic games, and the mean field games. Here all followers are experiencing learning-by-doing. The role of a third party is similar to industry associations, they supervise the leader's implementation and impose penalties for the defection with the discount factor. Then we obtain different forms of discount factors in different models and effective conditions to prevent defection.These results are consistent and the third party intervention is effective and maneuverable in practice.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily aims to address the issue of equilibrium credibility caused by time inconsistency in different types of Stackelberg games. Specifically, the paper introduces a third party to supervise the leader's behavior and impose penalties in case of default by the leader, ensuring that the game participants can maintain the Stackelberg equilibrium. ### Main Contributions and Problems Solved 1. **Introduction of a Third Party**: To overcome the time inconsistency problem of Stackelberg equilibrium, the authors introduce a third-party entity. This third party acts similarly to industry associations, government agencies, or banking institutions, responsible for supervising the leader's execution and imposing mandatory penalties when the leader deviates from their commitment. 2. **Three Different Types of Stackelberg Games**: The study examines three different types of Stackelberg games—discrete-time games, dynamic games, and mean-field games. In each type of game, the authors design appropriate penalty rules to ensure that the leader adheres to their commitments. 3. **Solving the Time Inconsistency Problem**: Due to time inconsistency, the leader may choose to deviate from their initial commitment at some future point to gain more benefits. The paper addresses this issue by introducing a third party and corresponding penalty mechanisms, making the Stackelberg equilibrium more feasible and credible in practice. ### Specific Research Content - **Discrete-Time Games**: A repeated oligopoly Stackelberg game model is considered, where in each game, the leader announces their optimal strategy, and the followers formulate their strategies based on the leader's choice. The paper proposes the concept of a discount factor to penalize the leader's default behavior. - **Dynamic Games**: The study extends to dynamic models, considering the case where the discount factor changes over time and provides corresponding theoretical results. - **Mean-Field Games**: In mean-field games, there is a significant leader and a large number of minor followers. The leader has a significant impact on other followers, while each follower, although unable to directly influence the leader, collectively has a substantial impact on the leader through their average state. The paper also introduces a third party and discusses the effective conditions of the penalty mechanism. In summary, the main goal of this paper is to overcome the time inconsistency problem in Stackelberg games by introducing a third party and penalty mechanisms, thereby ensuring the stability and feasibility of the equilibrium.

Stackelberg games with the third party

Dynamic Programming Approach to Discrete Time Dynamic Feedback Stackelberg Games with Independent and Dependent Followers.

A Three-level Stochastic Linear-quadratic Stackelberg Differential Game with Asymmetric Information

Inverse Game Theory for Stackelberg Games: the Blessing of Bounded Rationality

Efficient Stackelberg Strategies for Finitely Repeated Games

Decentralized Online Learning in General-Sum Stackelberg Games

Incentive Feedback Stackelberg Strategy in Mean-Field Type Stochastic Difference Games

The timing of third-party intervention in social conflict

Stackelberg vs. Nash in the Lottery Colonel Blotto Game

Solving Strongly Convex and Smooth Stackelberg Games Without Modeling the Follower

The Application of Non-Cooperative Stackelberg Game Theory in Behavioral Science: Social Optimality with any Number of Players

Distributed Stackelberg Equilibrium Seeking for Networked Multi-Leader Multi-Follower Games with A Clustered Information Structure

Consistency of Stackelberg and Nash Equilibria in Three-Player Leader-Follower Games

Imitative Follower Deception in Stackelberg Games

A Linear-quadratic Mean-Field Stochastic Stackelberg Differential Game with Random Exit Time

On Finding the Leader's Strategy in Quadratic Aggregative Stackelberg Pricing Games

Computing Algorithm for an Equilibrium of the Generalized Stackelberg Game

Differentiable Bilevel Programming for Stackelberg Congestion Games

Linear-Quadratic Stochastic Stackelberg Games of N Players for Time-Delay Systems and Related FBSDEs

Inverse Stackelberg Solutions for Games with Many Followers

Incentive Designs for Stackelberg Games with a Large Number of Followers and their Mean-Field Limits