Abstract:The increasing deployment of AI is shaping the future landscape of the internet, which is set to become an integrated ecosystem of AI agents. Orchestrating the interaction among AI agents necessitates decentralized, self-sustaining mechanisms that harmonize the tension between individual interests and social welfare. In this paper we tackle this challenge by synergizing reinforcement learning with principal-agent theory from economics. Taken separately, the former allows unrealistic freedom of intervention, while the latter struggles to scale in sequential settings. Combining them achieves the best of both worlds. We propose a framework where a principal guides an agent in a Markov Decision Process (MDP) using a series of contracts, which specify payments by the principal based on observable outcomes of the agent's actions. We present and analyze a meta-algorithm that iteratively optimizes the policies of the principal and agent, showing its equivalence to a contraction operator on the principal's Q-function, and its convergence to subgame-perfect equilibrium. We then scale our algorithm with deep Q-learning and analyze its convergence in the presence of approximation error, both theoretically and through experiments with randomly generated binary game-trees. Extending our framework to multiple agents, we apply our methodology to the combinatorial Coin Game. Addressing this multi-agent sequential social dilemma is a promising first step toward scaling our approach to more complex, real-world instances.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the problem of how to effectively coordinate the interactions among multiple AI agents in the future Internet environment with the wide deployment of artificial intelligence (AI) agents. Specifically, the paper focuses on ensuring efficient interactions among these AI agents in a decentralized and heterogeneous environment and finding a balance between individual interests and social welfare. #### Main challenges 1. **Decentralized coordination mechanism**: The future Internet will consist of multiple AI agents, which may be hosted by different entities, and they need a self - sustaining, decentralized coordination mechanism among them. 2. **Conflict between individual interests and social welfare**: Each AI agent has its own interest goals, which may lead to globally sub - optimal results, especially in multi - agent Sequential Social Dilemmas (SSDs), where this conflict is particularly evident. 3. **Limitations of existing methods**: Existing Reinforcement Learning (RL) methods can optimize the global objective, but usually assume centralized control over the training process of each agent, which is impractical in practical applications. And the Principal - Agent Theory in economics is difficult to extend to complex sequential decision - making scenarios. #### Solutions To solve the above problems, the author proposes a new framework that combines reinforcement learning and the principal - agent theory, namely "Principal - Agent Reinforcement Learning". This framework guides the behavior of agents through a series of contracts, in which the contract stipulates that the principal pays remuneration according to the observable results of the agent's behavior. The specific contributions are as follows: 1. **Framework in the single - agent case**: A general framework is proposed, in which the agent learns a strategy in a Markov Decision Process (MDP), and the principal guides the agent through a series of contracts. This framework explicitly models the usually misaligned preferences between the principal and the agent. 2. **Analysis from an economic perspective**: From a pure economic perspective, when there is full access to the MDP, the Subgame - Perfect Equilibrium (SPE) is studied, and a meta - algorithm is proposed and proven to converge to the SPE within a finite number of steps. 3. **Model - free reinforcement learning setting**: In the case of an unknown MDP, a strategy is learned by sampling random transitions and rewards. The meta - algorithm is implemented using Deep Q - learning, and its convergence is analyzed in the presence of approximation errors. 4. **Multi - agent extension**: The framework is extended to multiple agents and applied to multi - agent sequential social dilemma problems such as the combined Coin Game, verifying the effectiveness of the method. #### Summary This paper proposes a new framework by combining reinforcement learning and the principal - agent theory to solve the coordination problem among AI agents. This framework can not only handle complex sequential decision - making scenarios but also find a better balance between individual interests and social welfare, thus providing a promising solution for more complex real - world instances in the future.

Principal-Agent Reinforcement Learning: Orchestrating AI Agents with Contracts

Formal contracts mitigate social dilemmas in multi-agent reinforcement learning

Artificial Intelligence and Dual Contract

Formal Contracts Mitigate Social Dilemmas in Multi-Agent RL

Contractual Reinforcement Learning: Pulling Arms with Invisible Hands

Contracting With a Reinforcement Learning Agent by Playing Trick or Treat

Algorithmic Contract Design with Reinforcement Learning Agents

Multi-Agent Contracts

Prosocial or Selfish? Agents with Different Behaviors for Contract Negotiation Using Reinforcement Learning

The Problem of Social Cost in Multi-Agent General Reinforcement Learning: Survey and Synthesis

Deep multiagent reinforcement learning: challenges and directions

Modeling Moral Choices in Social Dilemmas with Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning

Solving Dynamic Principal-Agent Problems with a Rationally Inattentive Principal

Contracting with a Learning Agent

Generalized Principal-Agency: Contracts, Information, Games and Beyond

Multi-Principal Assistance Games

Adaptive Incentive Design with Multi-Agent Meta-Gradient Reinforcement Learning

New Perspectives in Online Contract Design

Learning to Incentivize Other Learning Agents

Cooperative Learning of Multi-Agent Systems Via Reinforcement Learning

Stochastic Principal-Agent Problems: Efficient Computation and Learning