Differential Forms vs Geometric Algebra: The quest for the best geometric language

Pablo Bañón Pérez,Maarten DeKieviet
2024-07-25
Abstract:Differential forms is a highly geometric formalism for physics used from field theories to General Relativity (GR) which has been a great upgrade over vector calculus with the advantages of being coordinate-free and carrying a high degree of geometrical content. In recent years, Geometric Algebra appeared claiming to be a unifying language for physics and mathematics with a high level of geometrical content. Its strength is based on the unification of the inner and outer product into a single geometric operation, and its easy interpretation. Given their similarities, in this article we compare both formalisms side-by-side to narrow the gap between them in literature. We present a direct translation including differential identities, integration theorems and various algebraic identities. As an illustrative example, we present the case of classical electrodynamics in both formalism and finish with their description of GR.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Mathematical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the applications of Differential Forms and Geometric Algebra (GA) in physics and attempts to establish a connection between the two to address the following issues: 1. **Unified Mathematical Language**: The paper aims to compare Differential Forms and Geometric Algebra to create a bridge that allows researchers familiar with Differential Forms to understand the advantages of Geometric Algebra, and those knowledgeable in Geometric Algebra to better read and comprehend literature related to Differential Forms. 2. **Unified Intuitive Explanation and Operation**: Differential Forms have certain limitations in intuitive explanation, especially for operations in high-dimensional spaces which are difficult to visualize. In contrast, Geometric Algebra provides a more intuitive and unified operational framework that can better handle geometric transformations, rotations, and other operations. 3. **Theoretical and Application Extension**: By comparing the differences between Differential Forms and Geometric Algebra, such as the presence or absence of mixed-grade elements and the complexity of geometric interpretations, the paper hopes to demonstrate how Geometric Algebra addresses some issues in Differential Forms, such as unifying different differential operators and extending the application range of the generalized Stokes' theorem. Specifically, the main objectives of the paper include: - **Introduction to Geometric Algebra**: Introducing the basic concepts and advantages of Geometric Algebra to readers unfamiliar with it. - **Comparative Analysis**: A detailed comparison of the similarities and differences between Differential Forms and Geometric Algebra, particularly regarding common algebraic identities, differential and integral theorems, etc. - **Case Analysis**: Demonstrating the specific applications of the two forms through examples from classical electrodynamics and further exploring their descriptions in general relativity. In summary, the core goal of this paper is to promote mutual understanding and communication between Differential Forms and Geometric Algebra, thereby providing physicists with more powerful tools to solve physical problems.