PenHeal: A Two-Stage LLM Framework for Automated Pentesting and Optimal Remediation

Junjie Huang,Quanyan Zhu

2024-07-25

Abstract:Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown significant potential in enhancing cybersecurity defenses against sophisticated threats. LLM-based penetration testing is an essential step in automating system security evaluations by identifying vulnerabilities. Remediation, the subsequent crucial step, addresses these discovered vulnerabilities. Since details about vulnerabilities, exploitation methods, and software versions offer crucial insights into system weaknesses, integrating penetration testing with vulnerability remediation into a cohesive system has become both intuitive and necessary. This paper introduces PenHeal, a two-stage LLM-based framework designed to autonomously identify and mitigate security vulnerabilities. The framework integrates two LLM-enabled components: the Pentest Module, which detects multiple vulnerabilities within a system, and the Remediation Module, which recommends optimal remediation strategies. The integration is facilitated through Counterfactual Prompting and an Instructor module that guides the LLMs using external knowledge to explore multiple potential attack paths effectively. Our experimental results demonstrate that PenHeal not only automates the identification and remediation of vulnerabilities but also significantly improves vulnerability coverage by 31%, increases the effectiveness of remediation strategies by 32%, and reduces the associated costs by 46% compared to baseline models. These outcomes highlight the transformative potential of LLMs in reshaping cybersecurity practices, offering an innovative solution to defend against cyber threats.

Cryptography and Security

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems this paper attempts to address are:

1. **Automated Penetration Testing**: Can large language models (LLMs) be used to automatically discover multiple vulnerabilities in a target system without human intervention?
2. **Automated Vulnerability Remediation**: Can large language models (LLMs) effectively and cost-efficiently automate the remediation of these vulnerabilities?

Specifically, the paper aims to address these issues by designing a two-stage LLM framework named **PenHeal**. This framework includes two main components: the **Pentest Module** and the **Remediation Module**.

- The **Pentest Module** is responsible for detecting vulnerabilities in the system, guiding the model to explore various attack paths through Counterfactual Prompting and an Instructor module.
- The **Remediation Module** transforms the detected vulnerabilities into actionable remediation strategies, generating and selecting the optimal remediation suggestions through an Adviser LLM and an Evaluator LLM.

The paper demonstrates through experimental results that **PenHeal** not only automates the identification and remediation of vulnerabilities but also significantly improves vulnerability coverage (31%), increases the effectiveness of remediation strategies (32%), and reduces associated costs (46%). These achievements highlight the potential of LLMs in reshaping cybersecurity practices, providing innovative solutions for defending against cyber threats.