Market Making with Exogenous Competition

Robert Boyce,Martin Herdegen,Leandro Sánchez-Betancourt

2024-07-25

Abstract:We study liquidity provision in the presence of exogenous competition. We consider a `reference market maker' who monitors her inventory and the aggregated inventory of the competing market makers. We assume that the competing market makers use a `rule of thumb' to determine their posted depths, depending linearly on their inventory. By contrast, the reference market maker optimises over her posted depths, and we assume that her fill probability depends on the difference between her posted depths and the competition's depths in an exponential way. For a linear-quadratic goal functional, we show that this model admits an approximate closed-form solution. We illustrate the features of our model and compare against alternative ways of solving the problem either via an Euler scheme or state-of-the-art reinforcement learning techniques.

Mathematical Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the issue of how liquidity providers (market makers) can optimize their quotes in the face of competitors in market trading. Specifically:

1. **Research Background**: The paper explores how a "reference market maker" adjusts its buy and sell quotes to maximize trading profits while minimizing inventory risk in the presence of multiple market makers.

2. **Core Issue**: When the reference market maker's orders are not executed, these orders are filled by other competitors, thereby affecting the future state of the market. Existing literature has not sufficiently considered the impact of such competition on the behavior of market makers.

3. **Model Construction**: The paper assumes that competitors set their buy and sell depths according to some heuristic (linearly dependent on their inventory), while the reference market maker optimizes its quotes to respond to market competition. Additionally, the probability of the reference market maker's orders being executed is exponentially related to the difference between its quotes and those of the competitors.

4. **Solution**: For a linear-quadratic objective function, the paper demonstrates that the model has an approximate closed-form solution and validates the effectiveness of the solution through numerical methods (such as the Euler scheme) and reinforcement learning techniques.

In summary, this paper aims to solve the problem of how market makers can optimize their quoting strategies in the face of competitors to balance their own inventory risk and market competition.