Abstract:The growing AI field faces trust, transparency, fairness, and discrimination challenges. Despite the need for new regulations, there is a mismatch between regulatory science and AI, preventing a consistent framework. A five-layer nested model for AI design and validation aims to address these issues and streamline AI application design and validation, improving fairness, trust, and AI adoption. This model aligns with regulations, addresses AI practitioner's daily challenges, and offers prescriptive guidance for determining appropriate evaluation approaches by identifying unique validity threats. We have three recommendations motivated by this model: authors should distinguish between layers when claiming contributions to clarify the specific areas in which the contribution is made and to avoid confusion, authors should explicitly state upstream assumptions to ensure that the context and limitations of their AI system are clearly understood, AI venues should promote thorough testing and validation of AI systems and their compliance with regulatory requirements.
Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence,Human-Computer Interaction,Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are the challenges of trust, transparency, fairness, and discrimination currently faced in the field of artificial intelligence (AI). Although new regulations are required to regulate the application of AI, there is currently a disconnect between regulatory science and AI, which hinders the establishment of a consistent framework. To address these issues, the author proposes a five - layer nested model for AI design and verification, aiming to simplify the design and verification process of AI applications and improve the fairness, credibility, and adoption rate of AI systems.
### Specific problems:
1. **Lack of trust and transparency**: AI systems lack sufficient transparency in practical applications, leading to users' distrust of their decision - making processes.
2. **Fairness and discrimination issues**: AI systems may exhibit unfair or discriminatory behavior in certain situations, affecting their social acceptance.
3. **Lack of regulations**: Existing regulations cannot effectively address the unique challenges of AI technology, resulting in legal and ethical risks in the development and application of AI.
4. **Disconnect between regulatory science and AI**: The rapid development of regulatory science and the AI field makes it difficult to coordinate between the two, and there is an urgent need to establish a unified framework.
### Solutions:
To address the above problems, the author proposes a five - layer nested model, which specifically includes the following layers:
- **Regulation Layer**: Ensure that the AI work flow complies with laws and regulations, especially those related to ethics and technology.
- **Domain Layer**: Ensure the applicability and compliance of AI applications within their specific domains.
- **Data Layer**: Interpret and analyze data, identify and mitigate biases and limitations in the data.
- **Model Layer**: Explain how the model works and ensure a balance between the interpretability and performance of the model.
- **Prediction Layer**: Explain the reasons for specific predictions and the variables behind them, ensuring the transparency and rationality of the predictions.
Through this layered approach, the nested model can help AI developers and regulatory agencies better understand and address various challenges in AI applications, thereby promoting the safe, reliable, and responsible development of AI technology.
### Core contributions of the paper:
1. **Provides a structured guide**: Helps to evaluate and verify AI applications and work flows, and identify the unique threats at each level.
2. **Bridges the gap between AI practitioners and regulators**: By clarifying the requirements at each level, promotes cooperation and understanding between the two parties.
3. **Emphasizes fairness, trust, and regulatory consistency**: Ensures that AI models are consistent with existing regulations, enhancing society's trust in AI technology.
In conclusion, by proposing a five - layer nested model, this paper aims to solve the problems of trust, transparency, fairness, and lack of regulations in the AI field, providing new ideas and methods for the safe and responsible development of AI technology.