Open-Set Biometrics: Beyond Good Closed-Set Models

Yiyang Su,Minchul Kim,Feng Liu,Anil Jain,Xiaoming Liu
2024-07-23
Abstract:Biometric recognition has primarily addressed closed-set identification, assuming all probe subjects are in the gallery. However, most practical applications involve open-set biometrics, where probe subjects may or may not be present in the gallery. This poses distinct challenges in effectively distinguishing individuals in the gallery while minimizing false detections. While it is commonly believed that powerful biometric models can excel in both closed- and open-set scenarios, existing loss functions are inconsistent with open-set evaluation. They treat genuine (mated) and imposter (non-mated) similarity scores symmetrically and neglect the relative magnitudes of imposter scores. To address these issues, we simulate open-set evaluation using minibatches during training and introduce novel loss functions: (1) the identification-detection loss optimized for open-set performance under selective thresholds and (2) relative threshold minimization to reduce the maximum negative score for each probe. Across diverse biometric tasks, including face recognition, gait recognition, and person re-identification, our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed loss functions, significantly enhancing open-set performance while positively impacting closed-set performance. Our code and models are available at <a class="link-external link-https" href="https://github.com/prevso1088/open-set-biometrics" rel="external noopener nofollow">this https URL</a>.
Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily proposes a new solution for open-set scenarios in biometric systems. Traditionally, biometric technology mainly focuses on closed-set identity verification problems, assuming that all objects to be verified exist in the database. However, in practical applications, objects not in the database (non-matching objects) are often encountered, which brings additional challenges to biometric systems, especially in distinguishing objects in the database while minimizing false detections. The main contributions of the paper can be summarized as follows: 1. **Problem Definition and Challenges**: - The paper points out that in open-set scenarios, existing loss functions such as triplet loss and softmax loss do not handle the problem of non-matching objects well. These loss functions usually assume that all objects belong to known categories, but in open-set situations, some objects to be verified may not belong to any known category. - Open-set evaluation metrics (such as False Negative Identification Rate at a specific False Positive Identification Rate, FNIR@FPIR) require setting a threshold based on the maximum similarity score of non-matching objects, which existing methods do not specifically optimize for. 2. **Proposed Solution**: - To simulate open-set evaluation conditions, the researchers created mini-batch data containing gallery and probe sets during training. - Two new loss functions are proposed: - **Identification-Detection Loss**: Used to optimize the model's identification and detection capabilities, ensuring that the model can correctly identify matching objects and effectively distinguish between matching and non-matching objects. - **Relative Threshold Minimization**: Aims to reduce the maximum similarity score between non-matching objects and objects in the gallery set, thereby lowering the open-set threshold. 3. **Experimental Results**: - Experiments were conducted on various biometric tasks, including face recognition, gait recognition, and person re-identification. The experimental results show that the proposed method can improve open-set performance while also enhancing closed-set performance. - Specifically, in the gait recognition task, compared to baseline methods, the new method significantly reduced FNIR@1%FPIR, demonstrating its effectiveness in open-set recognition tasks. In summary, this paper addresses key challenges in open-set biometric recognition by introducing new loss functions and validates their effectiveness across multiple biometric modalities.