Inequalities in Computational Thinking Among Incoming Students in an STEM Chilean University

Felipe González-Pizarro,Claudia López,Andrea Vásquez,Carlos Castro

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/TE.2023.3334193

2024-07-23

Abstract:While computational thinking arises as an essential skill worldwide, formal primary and secondary education in Latin America rarely incorporates mechanisms to develop it in their curricula. The extent to which students in the region acquire computational thinking skills remains largely unknown. To start addressing this void, this article presents findings from a cross-sectional study that characterizes the computational thinking abilities of incoming students at a Chilean university with a strong emphasis on STEM disciplines. Based on more than 500 responses, this study provides evidence of significant inequalities in computational thinking across gender, type of school (private or no), and prior programming knowledge. The discussion offers insights into how these disparities relate to contextual factors of the country, such as a highly socio-economically segregated educational system, public policies focused mainly on technology access, and heavy reliance on voluntary initiatives, to develop computational thinking. The findings can enlighten upcoming research endeavors and formulate strategies to create a more equitable field for students entering STEM degrees in nations facing similar circumstances.

Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore the development of computational thinking skills among high school graduates in a Latin American country (Chile) who have not received mandatory computational thinking training, and the differences in these skills based on gender and school type (private or public). Specifically, the study seeks to answer the following questions:

1. **RQ-1**: To what extent have students developed computational thinking skills in an educational system that does not mandate computational thinking training?
2. **RQ-2**: Is there a gender difference in computational thinking among students who qualify for entry into STEM university programs?
3. **RQ-3**: In a highly socio-economically stratified educational system, are there differences in computational thinking skills between different types of schools (private or non-private)?

### Background and Motivation

1. **Importance of Computational Thinking**:
- Computational thinking refers to the process of formulating problems in a way that enables information-processing agents (humans or machines) to effectively execute solutions.
- Globally, many countries have revised curricula to cultivate students' computational thinking skills and enhance these skills through programming.

2. **Situation in Latin America**:
- Formal basic education in Latin America rarely incorporates computational thinking into the curriculum.
- Although countries like Chile have some voluntary computational thinking training activities, these activities lack systematic and consistent implementation.

3. **Inequality Phenomena**:
- Previous studies have found a gender gap in computational thinking, which widens during primary and secondary education.
- Socio-economic status and racial structure are also believed to influence participation and development in computational thinking.

### Research Methods

1. **Research Design**:
- A cross-sectional study design was used to assess the computational thinking skills of students recently admitted to a STEM-focused university in Chile.
- Data was collected through an online questionnaire, including a Computational Thinking Test (CTt) and demographic information of the students.

2. **Measurement Tools**:
- The Computational Thinking Test (CTt) was used, which includes 32 multiple-choice questions covering concepts such as basic directions and sequences, conditional statements, loops, and functions.
- Information on students' gender, school type, and prior programming knowledge was also collected.

3. **Data Analysis**:
- Linear regression analysis was used to examine the relationship between computational thinking scores and gender, school type, and prior programming knowledge.
- Regression analysis was conducted separately for each component (basic directions and sequences, conditional statements, loops, and functions).

### Results

- The average computational thinking score of students was 25.5 (standard deviation of 5.45).
- The correct rates for problems of different difficulty levels were: 85% for simple problems, 65% for medium difficulty problems, and 45% for difficult problems.
- Male students had significantly higher computational thinking scores than female students.
- Students from private schools performed better than those from public or subsidized schools.
- Students with prior programming knowledge had higher computational thinking scores.

### Discussion

- The study reveals significant gender and school type differences in computational thinking among Chilean high school graduates.
- These differences may be related to Chile's highly socio-economically stratified educational system.
- The findings provide important references for future policies aimed at equitable STEM education.

### Conclusion

- This study provides empirical evidence for understanding the current state and inequalities in computational thinking education in Latin American countries.
- Future research should further explore how policies and educational interventions can reduce these inequalities and promote equity in STEM education.