Income, health, and cointegration

José A. Tapia Granados,Edward L. Ionides

2024-07-23

Abstract:Data for many nations show a long-run increase, over many decades, of income, indexed by GDP per capita, and population health, indexed by mortality or life expectancy at birth (LEB). However, the short-run and long-run relationships between these variables have been interpreted in different ways, and many controversies are still open. Some authors have claimed that the causal relationships between population health and income can be discovered using cointegration models. We show, however, that empirically testing a cointegration relation between LEB and GDP per capita is not a sound method to infer a causal link between health and income. For a given country it is easy to find computer-generated data or time series of real observations, related or unrelated to the country, that according to standard methods are also cointegrated with the country's LEB. More generally, given a trending time series, it is easy to find other series, observational or artificial, that appear cointegrated with it. Thus, standard cointegration methodology cannot distinguish whether cointegration relationships are spurious or causal.

General Economics