Abstract:We respond to the "Comment on "Reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance: time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response"", submitted by Yokouchi et al. (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2407.15682" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.15682">arXiv:2407.15682</a>), which refers to our preprint by Furuta et al (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2407.00309" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00309">arXiv:2407.00309</a>). In our preprint, we argued that the nonlinear impedance reported for materials with noncollinear magnetic textures, Gd$_3$Ru$_4$Al$_{12}$, YMn$_6$Sn$_6$, and FeSn$_2$, can be attributed to the considerable contribution of Joule-heating-induced AC electrical response, rather than the emergent electric field (EEF) due to the current-induced-dynamics of magnetic textures. In the comment by Yokouchi et al., the authors presented new data and concluded that the nonlinear impedance previously reported for Gd$_3$Ru$_4$Al$_{12}$ and YMn$_6$Sn$_6$ was not due to Joule heating but to the EEF. After reviewing their data and arguments, we found that (i) they misunderstood the applicability of the Joule heating model discussed in our preprint (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2407.00309" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00309">arXiv:2407.00309</a>), (ii) the data they presented in the comment are affected by extrinsic superconductivity caused during the microfabrication of specimens using focused ion beam (FIB) methods, and (iii) they misinterpreted their new data regarding the magnetic-field-angle dependence of the nonlinear impedance. Thus, we maintain that the nonlinear impedance reported in the literature and the comment includes a considerable impact from Joule heating. Furthermore, we demonstrate that for Gd$_3$Ru$_4$Al$_{12}$, the cross-sectional area dependence of the nonlinear impedance refutes the EEF scenario, and that the sign change of nonlinear resistance observed by Yokouchi \textit{et al.}~is not allowed from the perspective of stability associated with the current-driven EEF.

Comment on "Reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance: time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response"

Reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance: time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response

Reply to "Comment on "Reconsidering the nonlinear emergent inductance: time-varying Joule heating and its impact on the AC electrical response""

Current-driven Domain Wall Dynamics And Its Electric Signature In Ferromagnetic Nanowires

Energetic perspective on emergent inductance exhibited by magnetic textures in the pinned regime

Emergent Inductance from Spin Fluctuations in Strongly Correlated Magnets

Emergent inductors in non-helical magnets

Doping control of magnetism and emergent electromagnetic induction in high-temperature helimagnets

Challenges in extracting nonlinear current-induced phenomena in

Enhanced emergent electromagnetic inductance in Tb 5 Sb 3 due to highly disordered helimagnetism

Symmetry of the emergent inductance tensor exhibited by magnetic textures

Emergent electric field induced by current-driven domain wall motion in a room-temperature antiferromagnet FeSn2

Emergent electromagnetic induction beyond room temperature

Nonlinear magnon spin Nernst effect in antiferromagnets and strain-tunable pure spin current

Feedback-Induced Nonlinear Spin Dynamics in an Inhomogeneous Magnetic Field

Nonlinear longitudinal and transverse magnetoresistances due to current-induced magnon creation-annihilation processes

Role of material-dependent properties in THz field-derivative-torque-induced nonlinear magnetization dynamics

Challenges in extracting nonlinear current-induced phenomena in Ca2RuO4

Spin Currents and Magnon Dynamics in Insulating Magnets

Anomalous Hall effect from nonlinear magnetoelectric coupling