Auditing the Grid-Based Placement of Private Label Products on E-commerce Search Result Pages

Siddharth D Jaiswal,Abhisek Dash,Nitika Shroff,Yashwanth Babu Vunnam,Saptarshi Ghosh,Animesh Mukherjee

2024-07-20

Abstract:E-commerce platforms support the needs and livelihoods of their two most important stakeholders -- customers and producers/sellers. Multiple algorithmic systems, like ``search'' systems mediate the interactions between these stakeholders by connecting customers to producers with relevant items. Search results include (i) private label (PL) products that are manufactured/sold by the platform itself, as well as (ii) third-party products on advertised / sponsored and organic positions. In this paper, we systematically quantify the extent of PL product promotion on e-commerce search results for the two largest e-commerce platforms operating in India -- <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://Amazon.in" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> and Flipkart. By analyzing snapshots of search results across the two platforms, we discover high PL promotion on the initial result pages (~ 15% PLs are advertised on the first SERP of Amazon). Both platforms use different strategies to promote their PL products, such as placing more PLs on the advertised positions -- while Amazon places them on the first, middle, and last rows of the search results, Flipkart places them on the first two positions and the (entire) last column of the search results. We discover that these product placement strategies of both platforms conform with existing user attention strategies proposed in the literature. Finally, to supplement the findings from the collected data, we conduct a survey among 68 participants on Amazon Mechanical Turk. The click pattern from our survey shows that users strongly prefer to click on products placed at positions that correspond to the PL products on the search results of Amazon, but not so strongly on Flipkart. The click-through rate follows previously proposed theoretically grounded user attention distribution patterns in a two-dimensional layout.

Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction,Information Retrieval

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the extent of promotion of private label (PL) products on e-commerce platforms in search results and the impact of these promotion strategies on user behavior. Specifically, the study focuses on how India's two largest e-commerce platforms—Amazon (Amazon.in) and Flipkart—display private label products on search engine results pages (SERP) and explores whether this display method is biased towards the platform's own products, thereby affecting fairness.

Below is a summary of the main focus points of the paper:
1. **Extent of promotion of private label products**: The study quantifies the proportion of ad positions occupied by private label products in search results on Amazon and Flipkart. For example, approximately 15% of ad positions on the first page of Amazon's search results are occupied by private label products.
2. **Prominence of ad positions**: The study finds that these private label products are usually placed in prominent positions on the SERP, such as the top or bottom, which are more likely to attract user attention.
3. **User click behavior**: Through survey experiments, the study finds that users tend to click on products located in specific positions, which happen to coincide with the positions of Amazon's private label products.
4. **Legal and fairness issues**: The paper discusses the potential legal and fairness issues that such promotion strategies might raise, especially in the context of digital market regulations (such as the European Digital Markets Act).

In summary, this paper aims to reveal the actual extent to which e-commerce platforms promote private label products in search results and analyze the impact of this practice on user behavior and market competition fairness.