Abstract:An effective paradigm of multi-modal learning (MML) is to learn unified representations among modalities. From a causal perspective, constraining the consistency between different modalities can mine causal representations that convey primary events. However, such simple consistency may face the risk of learning insufficient or unnecessary information: a necessary but insufficient cause is invariant across modalities but may not have the required accuracy; a sufficient but unnecessary cause tends to adapt well to specific modalities but may be hard to adapt to new data. To address this issue, in this paper, we aim to learn representations that are both causal sufficient and necessary, i.e., Causal Complete Cause ($C^3$), for MML. Firstly, we define the concept of $C^3$ for MML, which reflects the probability of being causal sufficiency and necessity. We also propose the identifiability and measurement of $C^3$, i.e., $C^3$ risk, to ensure calculating the learned representations' $C^3$ scores in practice. Then, we theoretically prove the effectiveness of $C^3$ risk by establishing the performance guarantee of MML with a tight generalization bound. Based on these theoretical results, we propose a plug-and-play method, namely Causal Complete Cause Regularization ($C^3$R), to learn causal complete representations by constraining the $C^3$ risk bound. Extensive experiments conducted on various benchmark datasets empirically demonstrate the effectiveness of $C^3$R.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to address a key issue in representation learning within multimodal learning (MML): how to ensure that the learned representations possess both causal sufficiency and causal necessity. Specifically, existing multimodal learning methods may learn insufficient or unnecessary information when learning the consistency between different modalities. For example, a necessary but insufficient cause is consistent across different modalities but may lack the required accuracy; whereas a sufficient but unnecessary cause performs well in a specific modality but may struggle to adapt to new data. To tackle this challenge, the authors propose a new concept—**Causal Complete Cause (C3)**, and design a plug-in method—**Causal Complete Cause Regularization (C3R)**, to ensure that the learned representations possess both causal sufficiency and causal necessity. Through theoretical analysis and experimental validation, the authors demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of C3R. ### Key Contributions 1. **Definition of Causal Complete Cause (C3)**: The concept of C3 is proposed, and under the constraints of exogeneity and monotonicity, the identifiability and measurement method (C3 risk) of C3 are defined. 2. **Theoretical Analysis**: Through theoretical analysis, it is proven that C3 risk guarantees performance on both training and testing data, establishing a tight generalization bound. 3. **Proposing the C3R Method**: Based on the above theoretical results, the C3R method is proposed, which learns causally complete representations by limiting the upper bound of C3 risk. 4. **Experimental Validation**: Extensive experiments on multiple benchmark datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of C3R. ### Background and Motivation The goal of multimodal learning is to learn unified and robust representations from data of multiple modalities to accurately solve tasks. Existing multimodal learning methods typically achieve this by learning the consistency between different modalities, but this simple consistency may lead to learning insufficient or unnecessary information. For example, in a classification task, if all ducks have "webbed feet," then a representation based on consistency will include the "webbed feet" feature, but the model may make errors on samples of ducks without "webbed feet." This indicates that the learned representation contains sufficient but unnecessary information. ### Solution To solve this problem, the authors propose the following solutions: 1. **Define C3**: C3 reflects the probability that a representation is both causally sufficient and causally necessary. The authors also propose the identifiability and measurement method (C3 risk) of C3. 2. **Theoretical Guarantee**: Through theoretical analysis, it is proven that C3 risk can connect the risks of training and testing data, establishing a tight generalization bound. 3. **C3R Method**: A plug-in method C3R is proposed, which learns causally complete representations by limiting the upper bound of C3 risk. C3R can be applied to any multimodal learning model to improve its performance. ### Experimental Results Experimental results show that compared to existing multimodal learning methods, C3R significantly improves model performance on multiple benchmark datasets, especially in cases where modalities are partially damaged (as shown in Table 1). ### Conclusion By proposing the C3 and C3R methods, this paper addresses the key issue in representation learning within multimodal learning, ensuring that the learned representations possess both causal sufficiency and causal necessity. This provides new ideas and methods for further research in the field of multimodal learning.

On the Causal Sufficiency and Necessity of Multi-Modal Representation Learning

Seeking the Sufficiency and Necessity Causal Features in Multimodal Representation Learning

Causal Representation Learning from Multimodal Biological Observations

Comprehensive Semi-Supervised Multi-Modal Learning.

Causality-Inspired Fair Representation Learning for Multimodal Recommendation

Quantifying and Mitigating Unimodal Biases in Multimodal Large Language Models: A Causal Perspective

Multi-modal Causal Structure Learning and Root Cause Analysis

Revealing Multimodal Contrastive Representation Learning through Latent Partial Causal Models

Identifiable Causal Representation Learning: Unsupervised, Multi-View, and Multi-Environment

Multimodal Causal Reasoning Benchmark: Challenging Vision Large Language Models to Infer Causal Links Between Siamese Images

Causal disentanglement of multimodal data

Causal Meta-Reinforcement Learning for Multimodal Remote Sensing Data Classification

Causal multi-label learning for image classification

Multi-Instance Causal Representation Learning for Instance Label Prediction and Out-of-Distribution Generalization

Causality-based Cross-Modal Representation Learning for Vision-and-Language Navigation

Rethinking Modal-oriented Label Correlations for Multi-modal Multi-label Learning

Ensembling MML Causal Discovery

Multi-granularity Causal Structure Learning

Multimodal Understanding Through Correlation Maximization and Minimization

Mitigating Modality Prior-Induced Hallucinations in Multimodal Large Language Models via Deciphering Attention Causality

Multi-View Causal Representation Learning with Partial Observability