LLMs Assist NLP Researchers: Critique Paper (Meta-)Reviewing
Jiangshu Du,Yibo Wang,Wenting Zhao,Zhongfen Deng,Shuaiqi Liu,Renze Lou,Henry Peng Zou,Pranav Narayanan Venkit,Nan Zhang,Mukund Srinath,Haoran Ranran Zhang,Vipul Gupta,Yinghui Li,Tao Li,Fei Wang,Qin Liu,Tianlin Liu,Pengzhi Gao,Congying Xia,Chen Xing,Jiayang Cheng,Zhaowei Wang,Ying Su,Raj Sanjay Shah,Ruohao Guo,Jing Gu,Haoran Li,Kangda Wei,Zihao Wang,Lu Cheng,Surangika Ranathunga,Meng Fang,Jie Fu,Fei Liu,Ruihong Huang,Eduardo Blanco,Yixin Cao,Rui Zhang,Philip S. Yu,Wenpeng Yin
2024-10-03
Abstract:This work is motivated by two key trends. On one hand, large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable versatility in various generative tasks such as writing, drawing, and question answering, significantly reducing the time required for many routine tasks. On the other hand, researchers, whose work is not only time-consuming but also highly expertise-demanding, face increasing challenges as they have to spend more time reading, writing, and reviewing papers. This raises the question: how can LLMs potentially assist researchers in alleviating their heavy workload?
This study focuses on the topic of LLMs assist NLP Researchers, particularly examining the effectiveness of LLM in assisting paper (meta-)reviewing and its recognizability. To address this, we constructed the ReviewCritique dataset, which includes two types of information: (i) NLP papers (initial submissions rather than camera-ready) with both human-written and LLM-generated reviews, and (ii) each review comes with "deficiency" labels and corresponding explanations for individual segments, annotated by experts. Using ReviewCritique, this study explores two threads of research questions: (i) "LLMs as Reviewers", how do reviews generated by LLMs compare with those written by humans in terms of quality and distinguishability? (ii) "LLMs as Metareviewers", how effectively can LLMs identify potential issues, such as Deficient or unprofessional review segments, within individual paper reviews? To our knowledge, this is the first work to provide such a comprehensive analysis.
Computation and Language