Stringy Forces in the Black Hole Interior

Yoav Zigdon

2024-07-26

Abstract:Effective field theories break down inside large black holes on macroscopic scales when tidal forces are string-sized. If $r_0$ is the horizon radius and $\alpha'$ is the square of the string scale, the 4D Schwarzschild interior is strongly curved at $ \big(r_0 \alpha' \big)^{1/3}$. Infalling massless probes that reach this scale stretch and become excited strings. I generalize this picture for a wide class of black hole solutions in string theory. For the black hole dual to the large-$N$ BFSS model in a thermal state, and denoting $\ell_P$ the Planck length, tidal forces are stringy at $r_0 \left(\frac{r_0}{N^{1/3} \ell_P}\right)^{3/11}$, which is greater than the scale where string perturbation theory breaks down for sufficiently large $r_0/\ell_P$. For 4D Kerr, there is a range of spin parameters for which the inner horizon is to the future of the scale of stringy curvature. These results specify the portion of black hole interior solutions where effective field theory can be used; beyond these scales, one must resort to other methods.

High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

The problem that this paper "Stringy Forces in the Black Hole Interior" attempts to solve is when the effective field theory (EFT) breaks down when tidal forces reach the string scale inside large black holes. Specifically, the author Yoav Zigdon explores the scope of application and limitations of the effective field theory in different types of black hole interiors, especially within the framework of string theory, when the influence of tidal forces on falling probes reaches the string scale.

### Main research content:

1. **Background introduction**:
- It is usually assumed that the region inside a black hole until the singularity or close to the Planck scale \( \ell_P \) is a vacuum.
- There is a contradiction in this description: the principle of quantum unitary evolution is inconsistent with Hawking's calculation of the state of black - hole radiation.
- Some studies have pointed out that the effective field theory may break down near the black - hole horizon, and the concept of "firewall" has been proposed, that is, there are high - energy structures near the horizon, which will cause the falling observer to die.

2. **String theory effects**:
- In weakly - coupled string theory, there is a scale much larger than the Planck scale \( \ell_P \), namely the string scale \( \ell_s=\sqrt{\alpha'} \), at which the picture of general relativity (GR) will be significantly changed due to high - curvature terms.
- For a 4D Schwarzschild black hole, there is a larger scale \( r^* = \left(\sqrt{12\alpha' r_0}\right)^{1/3} \), at which string theory modifies the GR picture.

3. **Specific case analysis**:
- **Schwarzschild black hole**: By calculating the curvature invariants, the tidal forces at the string scale are determined, and the specific expression of the string scale \( r^* \) is given.
- **Kerr black hole**: The tidal forces inside the rotating black hole are analyzed, and it is found that for some rotation parameters, the inner horizon is outside the strong - curvature scale.
- **Charged black hole**: The tidal forces inside the charged black hole are discussed, and it is found that in some cases, the inner horizon is larger than the string scale but still smaller than the strong - curvature scale \( r^* \).
- **D0 - brane black hole**: The D0 - brane black hole corresponding to the thermal state of the BFSS model is studied, and the strong - curvature scale at the string scale is determined.
- **p - brane black hole**: The above results are generalized to the Horowitz - Strominger p - brane black hole solution, and the scale at which the effective field theory breaks down in different dimensions is explored.

### Conclusion:

- By calculating the tidal forces inside different types of black holes, the author determines the specific scale at which the effective field theory breaks down.
- These results indicate that beyond these scales, other methods must be used to describe the physical phenomena inside black holes.
- In particular, string theory provides a new physical picture at these scales, explaining how the falling probe is transformed into a string excitation mode.

### Formula summary:

- The strong - curvature scale of the Schwarzschild black hole:
\[
r^*=\left(\sqrt{12\alpha' r_0}\right)^{1/3}
\]
- The strong - curvature condition of the Kerr black hole:
\[
\tilde{r}^2+\frac{1}{4}\tilde{a}^2x^2\leq\left(\frac{12(\alpha')^2}{r_0^4}\right)^{1/3}
\]
- The strong - curvature scale of the charged black hole:
\[
r^*\sim r_0\left(\frac{r_0}{N^{1/3}\ell_P}\right)^{3/11}
\]

These formulas and analyses provide an important theoretical basis for understanding the physical phenomena inside black holes.