Theory of phonon spectroscopy with the quantum twisting microscope

Jiewen Xiao,Erez Berg,Leonid I. Glazman,Francisco Guinea,Shahal Ilani,Felix von Oppen

2024-07-17

Abstract:We develop a theory of probing phonon modes of van-der-Waals materials using the quantum twisting microscope. While elastic tunneling dominates the tunneling current at small twist angles, the momentum mismatch between the K-points of tip and sample at large twist angles can only be bridged by inelastic scattering. This allows for probing phonon dispersions along certain lines in reciprocal space by measuring the tunneling current as a function of twist angle and bias voltage. We illustrate this modality of the quantum twisting microscope by developing a systematic theory for graphene-graphene junctions. We show that beyond phonon dispersions, the tunneling current also encodes the strength of electron-phonon couplings. Extracting the coupling strengths for individual phonon modes requires careful consideration of various inelastic tunneling processes. These processes are associated with the intralayer and interlayer electron-phonon couplings and appear at different orders in a perturbative calculation of the tunneling current. We find that the dominant process depends on the particular phonon mode under consideration. Our results inform the quest to understand the origin of superconductivity in twisted bilayer graphene and provide a case study for quantum-twisting-microscope investigations of collective modes.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to develop a theoretical method for detecting phonon modes in van der Waals materials (such as graphene) using the Quantum Twisting Microscope (QTM). Specifically, the research aims to detect phonon dispersion and electron - phonon coupling strength in these materials by measuring the tunneling current at different twist angles and bias voltages. The paper pays special attention to these phenomena in the graphene - graphene junction and explores how to use these measurement results to understand the origin of superconductivity in magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene.

### Main problems and goals of the paper

1. **Detecting phonon dispersion**:
- The paper proposes a theoretical framework to detect phonon dispersion in van der Waals materials by measuring the tunneling current with the Quantum Twisting Microscope (QTM) at different twist angles and bias voltages. In particular, when the twist angle is large, the momentum mismatch can be compensated by inelastic scattering processes (such as phonon emission), which makes it possible to measure phonon dispersion.

2. **Measuring electron - phonon coupling strength**:
- Besides phonon dispersion, the tunneling current also encodes the electron - phonon coupling strength at different wave vectors. Extracting the coupling strength of a single phonon mode requires careful consideration of various inelastic tunneling processes, which are related to intra - layer and inter - layer electron - phonon couplings and appear at different orders in the perturbative calculation of the tunneling current.

3. **Understanding the superconducting mechanism**:
- The research results are helpful for understanding the origin of superconductivity in magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene. By measuring phonon dispersion and electron - phonon coupling strength, we can explore whether these phenomena are caused by the traditional electron - phonon coupling mechanism or by the strange mechanism caused by electron - electron correlations.

### Main findings and conclusions

- **Elastic tunneling process**:
- At a small twist angle, the tunneling current is mainly dominated by the elastic tunneling process, and at this time, the Fermi circles of the tip and the sample intersect.

- **Inelastic tunneling process**:
- At a large twist angle, due to momentum mismatch, inelastic tunneling processes (such as phonon emission) become important. These processes show threshold characteristics at specific bias voltages. By tracking the changes of these characteristics with the twist angle, a phonon dispersion map can be drawn.

- **Electron - phonon coupling**:
- The electron - phonon coupling mechanism is different for different phonon modes. For out - of - plane phonons, the inter - layer electron - phonon coupling plays a dominant role; while for in - plane phonons, both the inter - layer and intra - layer electron - phonon couplings contribute.

- **Experimental significance**:
- Measuring the phonon dispersion and electron - phonon coupling strength in the graphene - graphene junction by the Quantum Twisting Microscope can provide important experimental basis for understanding superconductivity and other collective modes in magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene.

In conclusion, through theoretical analysis and model building, this paper provides a systematic method for detecting phonon modes in van der Waals materials using the Quantum Twisting Microscope, which is of great significance for understanding the basic physical properties in these materials.