No Questions Asked: Effects of Transparency on Stablecoin Liquidity During the Collapse of Silicon Valley Bank

Walter Hernandez Cruz,Jiahua Xu,Paolo Tasca,Carlo Campajola
2024-07-16
Abstract:Fiat-pegged stablecoins are by nature exposed to spillover effects during market turmoil in Traditional Finance (TradFi). We observe a difference in TradFi market shocks impact between various stablecoins, in particular, USD Coin (USDC) and Tether USDT (USDT), the former with a higher reporting frequency and transparency than the latter. We investigate this, using top USDC and USDT liquidity pools in Uniswap, by adapting the Marginal Cost of Immediacy (MCI) measure to Uniswap's Automated Market Maker, and then conducting Difference-in-Differences analysis on MCI and Total Value Locked (TVL) in USD, as well as measuring liquidity concentration across different providers. Results show that the Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) event reduced USDC's TVL dominance over USDT, increased USDT's liquidity cost relative to USDC, and liquidity provision remained concentrated with pool-specific trends. These findings reveal a flight-to-safety behavior and counterintuitive effects of stablecoin transparency: USDC's frequent and detailed disclosures led to swift market reactions, while USDT's opacity and less frequent reporting provided a safety net against immediate impacts.
Trading and Market Microstructure,Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the issue of how the liquidity of stablecoins (specifically USDC and USDT) on decentralized exchanges (DEX) is affected during periods of turmoil in traditional financial markets (TradFi). Specifically, the authors focus on the impact of the Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) collapse on the liquidity of the two stablecoins and explore the role of transparency in this process. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **Impact of the SVB Event on USDC and USDT Liquidity**: - Study the changes in liquidity of USDC and USDT on Uniswap before and after the SVB event. - Compare the differences between USDC and USDT in terms of liquidity cost, total value locked (TVL), and liquidity concentration. 2. **Role of Transparency**: - Analyze the performance differences between USDC (high transparency) and USDT (low transparency) during market turmoil. - Explore how transparency affects investor behavior and market reactions. ### Research Background: - **SVB Event**: In March 2023, SVB Bank went bankrupt due to a funding chain break, causing market turmoil. - **Stablecoins**: USDC and USDT are the two most popular stablecoins, but they have significant differences in transparency and reporting frequency. - **Decentralized Exchange (DEX)**: Uniswap is a popular DEX that provides liquidity through an automated market maker (AMM) mechanism. ### Research Methods: - **Data Collection**: Analyze data from ten key liquidity pools on Uniswap, including trading pairs related to USDC and USDT. - **Indicator Analysis**: Use marginal cost of immediacy (MCI) to measure liquidity cost, calculate total value locked (TVL), and liquidity concentration (Gini coefficient). - **Event Study**: Use the difference-in-differences (DiD) method to analyze the impact of the SVB event on the liquidity of USDC and USDT. ### Main Findings: - **Liquidity Cost**: After the SVB event, the liquidity cost of USDC increased significantly, while the liquidity cost of USDT remained relatively low. - **Total Value Locked (TVL)**: The TVL of USDC decreased by approximately 19.40% relative to USDT. - **Liquidity Concentration**: Both USDC and USDT had high liquidity concentration (Gini coefficient >0.9), but the number of liquidity providers for USDC decreased significantly. - **Investor Behavior**: Investors tend to choose safer, more liquid assets during market turmoil, as evidenced by a shift from USDC to USDT. ### Conclusion: - **Double-Edged Sword Effect of Transparency**: The high transparency of USDC led to a rapid market response to its risks, while the low transparency of USDT provided temporary safety. - **Market Dynamics**: The SVB event revealed the vulnerability of the stablecoin market and the behavior patterns of investors under market pressure. This study provides valuable insights into the performance of stablecoins during market turmoil and highlights the complex role of transparency in financial stability.