Representing Rule-based Chatbots with Transformers

Dan Friedman,Abhishek Panigrahi,Danqi Chen

2024-07-16

Abstract:Transformer-based chatbots can conduct fluent, natural-sounding conversations, but we have limited understanding of the mechanisms underlying their behavior. Prior work has taken a bottom-up approach to understanding Transformers by constructing Transformers for various synthetic and formal language tasks, such as regular expressions and Dyck languages. However, it is not obvious how to extend this approach to understand more naturalistic conversational agents. In this work, we take a step in this direction by constructing a Transformer that implements the ELIZA program, a classic, rule-based chatbot. ELIZA illustrates some of the distinctive challenges of the conversational setting, including both local pattern matching and long-term dialog state tracking. We build on constructions from prior work -- in particular, for simulating finite-state automata -- showing how simpler constructions can be composed and extended to give rise to more sophisticated behavior. Next, we train Transformers on a dataset of synthetically generated ELIZA conversations and investigate the mechanisms the models learn. Our analysis illustrates the kinds of mechanisms these models tend to prefer -- for example, models favor an induction head mechanism over a more precise, position based copying mechanism; and using intermediate generations to simulate recurrent data structures, like ELIZA's memory mechanisms. Overall, by drawing an explicit connection between neural chatbots and interpretable, symbolic mechanisms, our results offer a new setting for mechanistic analysis of conversational agents.

Computation and Language,Artificial Intelligence,Machine Learning

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem this paper attempts to address is understanding the underlying mechanisms of Transformer-based chatbots (such as ChatGPT) when engaging in fluent and natural conversations. Although these models can generate conversations that sound very natural, the current understanding of how they achieve this capability is still limited. To this end, researchers have adopted a construction method by building specific task-oriented Transformers to identify the explicit mechanisms they might use. However, this approach mainly focuses on single-sentence tasks, and how to extend it to more natural conversational scenarios remains an open question.

Specifically, this paper proposes using rule-based chatbots to analyze the formal and mechanistic methods of neural network chatbots. The authors chose a classic rule-based chatbot—ELIZA—as the subject of study. ELIZA not only demonstrates the ability for local pattern matching but also has the functionality for long-term conversation state tracking, making it an ideal case for studying the internal workings of neural network chatbots. The paper constructs a Transformer model capable of implementing the ELIZA algorithm and analyzes the trained model to understand how these models learn and execute conversational tasks. The research focuses on challenging subtasks such as accurately replicating user input, memory queue mechanisms, and response loop mechanisms.

Overall, by linking neural network chatbots with interpretable symbolic mechanisms, this study provides a new research framework for algorithm-level understanding of conversational agents. This not only helps deepen our understanding of the working principles of existing models but also provides direction for future improvements in the interpretability and scientific rigor of these models.