Reevaluating the cosmological redshift: insights into inhomogeneities and irreversible processes

P. Tremblin,G. Chabrier

2024-07-15

Abstract:Understanding the expansion of the Universe remains a profound challenge in fundamental physics. The complexity of solving General Relativity equations in the presence of intricate, inhomogeneous flows has compelled cosmological models to rely on perturbation theory in a homogeneous FLRW background. This approach accounts for a redshift of light encompassing contributions from both the cosmological background expansion along the photon's trajectory and Doppler effects at emission due to peculiar motions. However, this computation of the redshift is not covariant, as it hinges on specific coordinate choices that may distort physical interpretations of the relativity of motion. In this study, we show that peculiar motions, when tracing the dynamics along time-like geodesics, must contribute to the redshift of light through a local volume expansion factor, in addition to the background expansion. By employing a covariant approach to redshift calculation, we address the central question of whether the cosmological principle alone guarantees that the averaged local volume expansion factor matches the background expansion. We establish that this holds true only in scenarii characterized by a reversible evolution of the Universe, where inhomogeneous expansion and compression modes mutually compensate. In the presence of irreversible processes, such as the dissipation of large-scale compression modes through matter virialization and associated entropy production, the averaged expansion factor becomes dominated by expansion in voids that cannot be compensated anymore by compression in virialized structures. Our approach shows that entropy production due to irreversible processes during the formation of structures plays the same role as an effective, time-dependent cosmological constant, i.e. dynamical dark energy, without the need to invoke new unknown physics.

Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to re - evaluate the cosmological redshift, especially to explore the influence of inhomogeneities and irreversible processes on the cosmological redshift. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Traditional explanation of the cosmological redshift**:
- Traditionally, the cosmological redshift is explained by the solution of the Friedmann - Lemaitre - Robertson - Walker (FLRW) metric in a homogeneous background. This method takes into account the cosmic background expansion along the photon path and the Doppler effect due to special motion at the time of emission.
- However, this calculation method is not covariant because it depends on a specific choice of coordinates and may distort the physical interpretation of relativistic motion.

2. **Influence of inhomogeneities and irreversible processes**:
- The paper points out that special motion must contribute to the redshift of light through the local volume expansion factor in the dynamical process along timelike geodesics, not just the background expansion.
- The author uses a covariant method to calculate the redshift and explores the question of whether the cosmological principle can ensure that the average value of the local volume expansion factor matches the background expansion.

3. **Physical significance of irreversible processes**:
- In the presence of irreversible processes, such as the dissipation of large - scale compression modes through the virialization of matter and the associated entropy production, the average value of the local volume expansion factor will be dominated by expanding voids and cannot be compensated by the compression in the virialized structure.
- In this case, if the evolution of the universe generally follows the background evolution, it will lead to a significant violation of the second law of thermodynamics.
- The author believes that the entropy production in the process of structure formation is functionally similar to an effective time - dependent cosmological constant, that is, dynamic dark energy, without the need to introduce new unknown physics.

### Main conclusions

- **Importance of the covariant method**: Using a covariant method to calculate the redshift can more accurately describe the influence of inhomogeneities and irreversible processes on the redshift.
- **Significant influence of irreversible processes**: Irreversible processes such as the virialization of matter will cause the average value of the local volume expansion factor to deviate from the background expansion, thus affecting the measurement of the cosmological redshift.
- **Constraints of the second law of thermodynamics**: If the evolution of the universe generally follows the background evolution and the entropy production caused by irreversible processes cannot be ignored, then this will violate the second law of thermodynamics.
- **Necessity of re - evaluating the cosmological model**: The paper emphasizes the need to re - evaluate the influence of inhomogeneities and irreversible processes on the cosmological model in order to better understand the complex dynamics of the universe.

Through these studies, the paper provides a new perspective for understanding the inhomogeneities and irreversible processes of the universe and emphasizes the importance of these factors in the cosmological redshift.