A. Uranga,E. Akhmatskaya,D. Sokolovski
Abstract:Uncertainty principle forbids one to determine which of the two paths a quantum system has travelled, unless interference between the alternatives had been destroyed by a measuring device, e.g., by a pointer. One can try to weaken the coupling between the device and the system, in order to avoid the veto. We demonstrate, however, that a weak pointer is at the same time an inaccurate one, and the information about the path taken by the system in each individual trial is inevitably lost. We show also that a similar problem occurs if a classical system is monitored by an inaccurate quantum meter. In both cases one can still determine some characteristic of the corresponding statistical ensemble, a relation between path probabilities in the classical case, and a relation between the probability amplitudes if a quantum system is involved.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the "which way?" problem in quantum mechanics, that is, in the double - slit experiment or multi - path interference experiment, how to determine which path a quantum system (such as a photon or an electron) has specifically passed through. This problem is closely related to the uncertainty principle, because according to the uncertainty principle, any attempt to measure path information will inevitably destroy the interference phenomenon between paths and change the final state of the system.
### Specific Problem Description
1. **Limitations of the Uncertainty Principle**:
- The uncertainty principle prohibits us from simultaneously and precisely knowing the path information of a quantum system and maintaining its interference characteristics. Any measuring device (such as a pointer) used to determine the path will perturb the system, thus changing the motion trajectory of the system and the probability of reaching the final state.
2. **Application of Weak - Coupling Pointers**:
- In order to bypass this limitation, some studies have proposed using weak - coupling pointers (weak pointer), that is, the coupling between the pointer and the system is very weak, in the hope of obtaining path information without significantly destroying the interference. However, the effectiveness and reliability of this method still need to be verified.
3. **Weak Values and Statistical Characteristics**:
- Even if the weak - coupling pointers cannot provide path information in a single trial, they can still reveal certain statistical characteristics. For example, the relationship between path probabilities or probability amplitudes can be estimated through multiple trials.
### Research Objectives
The main objective of the paper is to analyze the performance of weak - coupling pointers in the quantum double - slit experiment (the simplest two - path problem) and explore whether they can effectively obtain path information without destroying the interference phenomenon. Specifically:
- **Accuracy of Weak - Coupling Pointers**: Study the performance of weak - coupling pointers at different precisions, especially in high - precision and low - precision cases, the distribution of pointer readings and their influence on path information.
- **Extraction of Statistical Characteristics**: Even if the path information in a single trial cannot be determined, explore whether certain statistical characteristics of the system, such as the relationship between path probabilities or probability amplitudes, can be extracted through multiple trials.
### Main Conclusions
The paper draws the following conclusions through analogical analysis of classical and quantum systems:
- **Limitations of Weak - Coupling Pointers**: Although weak - coupling pointers can preserve the interference phenomenon to a certain extent, the accuracy of their readings is extremely low and they cannot determine the specific path of the system in a single trial.
- **Acquisition of Statistical Information**: Although the path information cannot be determined in a single trial, statistical information about path probabilities or probability amplitudes can be extracted through multiple trials.
- **Avoidance of False Inferences**: Emphasize the misleading conclusions that may occur when using multiple weak - coupling pointers for measurement, such as mistakenly believing that the system exists in multiple paths simultaneously. These conclusions can be verified and corrected by introducing more accurate measurement means.
In summary, this paper aims to deeply explore the application and limitations of weak - coupling pointers in quantum path measurement, and through the comparison between classical and quantum systems, reveals the important significance of weak - value measurement in quantum mechanics.