Automatic structures and the problem of natural well-orderings

Lev D. Beklemishev,Fedor N. Pakhomov

2024-07-14

Abstract:We explore the idea of using automatic and similar kind of presentations of structures to deal with the conceptual problem of natural proof-theoretic ordinal notations. We conclude that this approach still does not meet the goals.

Logic

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Automatic Structures: Richness and Limitations

B Khoussainov,A Nies,S Rubin,F Stephan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2168/lmcs-3(2:2)2007

2007-01-01

Logical Methods in Computer Science

Abstract:We study the existence of automatic presentations for various algebraic structures. An automatic presentation of a structure is a description of the universe of the structure by a regular set of words, and the interpretation of the relations by synchronised automata. Our first topic concerns characterising classes of automatic structures. We supply a characterisation of the automatic Boolean algebras, and it is proven that the free Abelian group of infinite rank, as well as certain Fraisse limits, do not have automatic presentations. In particular, the countably infinite random graph and the random partial order do not have automatic presentations. Furthermore, no infinite integral domain is automatic. Our second topic is the isomorphism problem. We prove that the complexity of the isomorphism problem for the class of all automatic structures is \Sigma_1^1-complete.
Model Theoretic Complexity of Automatic Structures

Bakhadyr Khoussainov,Mia Minnes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0809.3425

2008-09-20

Abstract:We study the complexity of automatic structures via well-established concepts from both logic and model theory, including ordinal heights (of well-founded relations), Scott ranks of structures, and Cantor-Bendixson ranks (of trees). We prove the following results: 1) The ordinal height of any automatic well- founded partial order is bounded by \omega^\omega ; 2) The ordinal heights of automatic well-founded relations are unbounded below the first non-computable ordinal; 3) For any computable ordinal there is an automatic structure of Scott rank at least that ordinal. Moreover, there are automatic structures of Scott rank the first non-computable ordinal and its successor; 4) For any computable ordinal, there is an automatic successor tree of Cantor-Bendixson rank that ordinal.

Logic
Semiautomatic Structures

Sanjay Jain,Bakhadyr Khoussainov,Frank Stephan,Dan Teng,Siyuan Zou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00224-017-9792-7

IF: 0.616

2017-01-01

Theory of Computing Systems

Abstract:Semiautomatic structures generalise automatic structures in the sense that for some of the relations and functions in the structure one only requires the derived relations and functions are automatic when all but one input are filled with constants. One can also permit that this applies to equality in the structure so that only the sets of representatives equal to a given element of the structure are regular while equality itself is not an automatic relation on the domain of representatives. It is shown that one can find semiautomatic representations for the field of rationals and also for finite algebraic field extensions of it. Furthermore, one can show that infinite algebraic extensions of finite fields have semiautomatic representations in which the addition and equality are both automatic. Further prominent examples of semiautomatic structures are term algebras, any relational structure over a countable domain with a countable signature and any permutation algebra with a countable domain. Furthermore, examples of structures which fail to be semiautomatic are provided.
From Automatic Structures to Borel Structures

Greg Hjorth,Bakh Khoussainov,Antonio Montalban,Andre Nies

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/lics.2008.28

2008-01-01

Abstract:We study the classes of Büchi and Rabin automatic structures. For Büchi (Rabin) automatic structures their domains consist of infinite strings (trees), and the basic relations, including the equality relation, and graphs of operations are recognized by Büchi (Rabin) automata. A Büchi (Rabin) automatic structure is injective if different infinite strings (trees) represent different elements of the structure. The first part of the paper is devoted to understanding the automata-theoretic content of the well-known Löwenheim-Skolem theorem in model theory. We provide automata-theoretic versions of Löwenheim-Skolem theorem for Rabin and Büchi automatic structures. In the second part, we address the following two well-known open problems in the theory of automatic structures: Does every Büchi automatic structure have an injective Büchi presentation? Does every Rabin automatic structure have an injective Rabin presentation? We provide examples of Büchi structures without injective Büchi and Rabin presentations. To answer these questions we introduce Borel structures and usesome of the basic properties of Borel sets and isomorphisms. Finally, in the last part of the paper we study the isomorphism problem for Büchi automatic structures.
Automatic Equivalence Structures of Polynomial Growth.

Moses Ganardi,Bakhadyr Khoussainov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4230/lipics.csl.2020.21

2020-01-01

Abstract:In this paper we study the class EqP of automatic equivalence structures of the form 𝔈=(D, E) where the domain D is a regular language of polynomial growth and E is an equivalence relation on D. Our goal is to investigate the following two foundational problems (in the theory of automatic structures) aimed for the class EqP. The first is to find algebraic characterizations of structures from EqP, and the second is to investigate the isomorphism problem for the class EqP. We provide full solutions to these two problems. First, we produce a characterization of structures from EqP through multivariate polynomials. Second, we present two contrasting results. On the one hand, we prove that the isomorphism problem for structures from the class EqP is undecidable. On the other hand, we prove that the isomorphism problem is decidable for structures from EqP with domains of quadratic growth.
Automatic Structures: Overview and Future Directions.

Bakhadyr Khoussainov,Sasha Rubin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.25596/jalc-2003-287

2003-01-01

Abstract:The theory of automatic structures is presented in relation to model theory, algebra, complexity theory and automata theory. We survey basic results and present possible directions for future research in the area.
Some Thoughts On Automatic Structures

bakhadyr khoussainov,sasha rubin

2002-01-01

Abstract:Abstract: this paper is twofold. On the one hand, we present the theoryof automatic structures from the points of view of model theory, algebra, complexitytheory, and automata theory. On the other hand, we survey basic results and presentpossible directions for future research in the area. The theory of automatic structuresas such is relatively new though its roots go back to the beginning of the developmentsof finite automata theory. The term automatic structure in the sense presented in thispaper ...
Definability and Regularity in Automatic Structures

Bakhadyr Khoussainov,Sasha Rubin,Frank Stephan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-24749-4_39

2004-01-01

Abstract:An automatic structure A is one whose domain A and atomic relations are finite automaton (FA) recognisable. A structure isomorphic to A is called automatically presentable. Suppose R is an FA recognisable relation on A. This paper concerns questions of the following type. For which automatic presentations of A is (the image of) R also FA recognisable? To this end we say that a relation R is intrinsically regular in a structure A if it is FA recognisable in every automatic presentation of the structure. For example, in every automatic structure all relations definable in first order logic are intrinsically regular. We characterise the intrinsically regular relations of some automatic fragments of arithmetic in the first order logic extended with quantifiers There Exists(infinity) interpreted as 'there exists infinitely many', and There Exists((i)) interpreted as 'there exists a multiple of i many'.
Three Lectures on Automatic Structures

Bakhadyr Khoussainov,Mia Minnes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0809.3430

2008-09-20

Abstract:This paper grew out of three tutorial lectures on automatic structures given by the first author at the Logic Colloquium 2007. We discuss variants of automatic structures related to several models of computation: word automata, tree automata, Buchi automata, and Rabin automata. Word automata process finite strings, tree automata process finite labeled trees, Buchi automata process infinite strings, and Rabin automata process infinite binary labeled trees. Automatic structures are mathematical objects which can be represented by (word, tree, Buchi, or Rabin) automata. The study of properties of automatic structures is a relatively new and very active area of research.

Logic
On Automatic Partial Orders

B Khoussainov,S Rubin,F Stephan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/LICS.2003.1210056

2003-01-01

Abstract:We investigate partial orders that are computable, in a precise sense, by finite automata. Our emphasis is on trees and linear orders. We study the relationship between automatic linear orders and trees in terms of rank functions that are versions of Cantor-Bendixson rank. We prove that automatic linear orders and automatic trees have finite rank. As an application we provide a procedure for deciding the isomorphism problem for automatic ordinals. We also investigate the complexity and definability of infinite paths in automatic trees. In particular we show that every infinite path in an automatic tree with countably many infinite paths is a regular language.
Automatic Linear Orders and Trees

Bakhadyr Khoussainov,Sasha Rubin,Frank Stephan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/1094622.1094625

2005-01-01

ACM Transactions on Computational Logic

Abstract:We investigate partial orders that are computable, in a precise sense, by finite automata. Our emphasis is on trees and linear orders. We study the relationship between automatic linear orders and trees in terms of rank functions that are related to Cantor--Bendixson rank. We prove that automatic linear orders and automatic trees have finite rank. As an application we provide a procedure for deciding the isomorphism problem for automatic ordinals. We also investigate the complexity and definability of infinite paths in automatic trees. In particular, we show that every infinite path in an automatic tree with countably many infinite paths is a regular language.
Automated reasoning for proving non-orderability of groups

Alexei Lisitsa,Zipei Nie,Alexei Vernitski

2023-10-10

Abstract:We demonstrate how a generic automated theorem prover can be applied to establish the non-orderability of groups. Our approach incorporates various tools such as positive cones, torsions, generalised torsions and cofinal elements.

Geometric Topology,Group Theory
Defining Algorithmically Presented Structures in First Order Logic

Bakh Khoussainov,Nadim Kasymov,Nodira Karimova

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3661814.3662120

2024-01-01

Abstract:We aim to describe the isomorphism types of infinite structures in the language of first-order logic. This pursuit holds importance in logic in computer science, encompassing model theory, descriptional complexity, and the foundations of computability. We introduce the notion of quasi-axiomatizability aimed at describing the isomorphism types of structures. Our focus centers on two classes of algorithmically presented structures. The first is the class of structures for which the positive atomic diagrams are computably enumerable. We call these structures positive structures. The second is the class of structures for which the negative atomic diagrams are computably enumerable. We call these structures negative structures. We study quasi-axiomatizability of structures from these classes by there exists, for all, there exists for all, for all there exists-sentences in expansions of languages. Our work is a contribution to the interplay between expressive power of first-order logic, computability, and model theory.
Proof-theoretic strengths of the well-ordering principles

Toshiyasu Arai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00153-019-00689-4

2019-07-30

Archive for Mathematical Logic

Abstract:In this note the proof-theoretic ordinal of the well-ordering principle for the normal functions $\mathsf {g}$ on ordinals is shown to be equal to the least fixed point of $\mathsf {g}$. Moreover corrections to the previous paper (Arai in Arch Math Log 57:649–664, <a href="#CR3">2017</a>) are made.

mathematics,logic
On the Hierarchy of Natural Theories

James Walsh

2024-02-16

Abstract:It is a well-known empirical phenomenon that natural axiomatic theories are pre-well-ordered by consistency strength. Without a precise mathematical definition of "natural," it is unclear how to study this phenomenon mathematically. We will discuss the significance of this problem and survey some strategies that have recently been developed for addressing it. These strategies emphasize the role of reflection principles and ordinal analysis and draw on analogies with research in recursion theory. We will conclude with a discussion of open problems and directions for future research.

Logic
On Computably Enumerable Structures

B. Khoussainov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1134/s1995080214040180

2014-01-01

Lobachevskii Journal of Mathematics

Abstract:This is a short article based on the plenary lecture presented by the author at Algebra Computability and Logic conference in Kazan, June 1–6, 2014. The paper is a new approach that introduces effectiveness into the study of algebraic structures. In this approach the initial objects are the domains of the form ω/E, where E is an equivalence relation on ω. In this set-up one investigates effective algebraic structures that are admitted by domains of the formω/E. This lecture was motivated by the papers [2, 20, 21], open questions in [17], and is based on the papers [15, 16, 19, 23].
Formalising Ordinal Partition Relations Using Isabelle/HOL

Mirna Džamonja,Angeliki Koutsoukou-Argyraki,Lawrence C. Paulson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10586458.2021.1980464

2021-04-20

Abstract:This is an overview of a formalisation project in the proof assistant Isabelle/HOL of a number of research results in infinitary combinatorics and set theory (more specifically in ordinal partition relations) by Erdős--Milner, Specker, Larson and Nash-Williams, leading to Larson's proof of the unpublished result by E.C. Milner asserting that for all $m \in \mathbb{N}$, $\omega^\omega\arrows(\omega^\omega, m)$. This material has been recently formalised by Paulson and is available on the Archive of Formal Proofs; here we discuss some of the most challenging aspects of the formalisation process. This project is also a demonstration of working with Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory in higher-order logic.

Logic
Model-checking positive equality free logic on a fixed structure (direttissima)

Manuel Bodirsky,Marcin Kozik,Florent Madelaine,Barnaby Martin,Michal Wrona

2024-08-25

Abstract:We give a new, direct proof of the tetrachotomy classification for the model-checking problem of positive equality-free logic parameterised by the model. The four complexity classes are Logspace, NP-complete, co-NP-complete and Pspace-complete. The previous proof of this result relied on notions from universal algebra and core-like structures called U-X-cores. This new proof uses only relations, and works for infinite structures also in the distinction between Logspace and NP-hard under Turing reductions. For finite domains, the membership in NP and co-NP follows from a simple argument, which breaks down already over an infinite set with a binary relation. We develop some interesting new algorithms to solve NP and co-NP membership for a variety of infinite structures. We begin with those first-order definable in (Q;=), the so-called equality languages, then move to those first-order definable in (Q;<), the so-called temporal languages. However, it is first-order expansions of the Random Graph (V,E) that provide the most interesting examples. In all of these cases, the derived classification is a tetrachotomy between Logspace, NP-complete, co-NP-complete and Pspace-complete.

Logic in Computer Science
Universal quantification makes automatic structures hard to decide

Christoph Haase,Radosław Piórkowski

2024-05-14

Abstract:Automatic structures are structures whose universe and relations can be represented as regular languages. It follows from the standard closure properties of regular languages that the first-order theory of an automatic structure is decidable. While existential quantifiers can be eliminated in linear time by application of a homomorphism, universal quantifiers are commonly eliminated via the identity $\forall{x}. \Phi \equiv \neg (\exists{x}. \neg \Phi)$. If $\Phi$ is represented in the standard way as an NFA, a priori this approach results in a doubly exponential blow-up. However, the recent literature has shown that there are classes of automatic structures for which universal quantifiers can be eliminated by different means without this blow-up by treating them as first-class citizens and not resorting to double complementation. While existing lower bounds for some classes of automatic structures show that a singly exponential blow-up is unavoidable when eliminating a universal quantifier, it is not known whether there may be better approaches that avoid the naïve doubly exponential blow-up, perhaps at least in restricted settings.

Logic in Computer Science
Automatic Structures and Groups

Bakhadyr Khoussainov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-21254-3_2

2011-01-01

Abstract:Automata theory has unified many areas of computer science and mathematics. These include group theory (Thurston automatic groups [11], branch and self similar groups [1] [24]), computable model theory (the theory of automatic structures [5] [17] [16]), finite model theory, algorithms and decidability, logic, model checking and verification.

Automatic structures and the problem of natural well-orderings

Automatic Structures: Richness and Limitations

Model Theoretic Complexity of Automatic Structures

Semiautomatic Structures

From Automatic Structures to Borel Structures

Automatic Equivalence Structures of Polynomial Growth.

Automatic Structures: Overview and Future Directions.

Some Thoughts On Automatic Structures

Definability and Regularity in Automatic Structures

Three Lectures on Automatic Structures

On Automatic Partial Orders

Automatic Linear Orders and Trees

Automated reasoning for proving non-orderability of groups

Defining Algorithmically Presented Structures in First Order Logic

Proof-theoretic strengths of the well-ordering principles

On the Hierarchy of Natural Theories

On Computably Enumerable Structures

Formalising Ordinal Partition Relations Using Isabelle/HOL

Model-checking positive equality free logic on a fixed structure (direttissima)

Universal quantification makes automatic structures hard to decide

Automatic Structures and Groups