The principled-parameterized approach to gravitational collapse

Héloïse Delaporte,Astrid Eichhorn

2024-07-11

Abstract:New physics beyond General Relativity impacts black-hole spacetimes. The effects of new physics can be investigated in a largely theory-agnostic way by following the principled-parameterized approach. In this approach, a classical black-hole metric is upgraded by following a set of principles, such as regularity, i.e., the absence of curvature singularities. We expect these principles to hold in many theories beyond General Relativity. In the present paper, we implement this approach for time-dependent spacetimes describing gravitational collapse. We find that the Vaidya spacetime becomes regular through the same modification of the spacetime metric as stationary black-hole spacetimes [1-3]. We investigate null geodesics and find indications that the modification is even sufficient to render null geodesics future complete. Finally, we find that the modification of the spacetime structure results in violations of the null energy condition in a finite region inside the apparent horizon of the black hole that forms. Null geodesics are attracted to the boundary of this region, such that the new-physics effects are shielded from asymptotic observers. An exception occurs, if the classical spacetime has a naked singularity. Then, the upgraded spacetime is singularity-free and null geodesics from the regular core can escape towards asymptotic observers.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to improve the spacetime metric describing gravitational collapse through a principled - parameterized approach, thereby eliminating singularities and making spacetime complete. Specifically, the author explores the influence of new physics beyond General Relativity (GR) on black - hole spacetime and proposes a method to improve Vaidya spacetime so that it can avoid singularities and incomplete geodesics when describing gravitational collapse.

### Main problems

1. **The singularity problem in gravitational collapse**:
- The traditional Vaidya spacetime describes the spherically symmetric gravitational collapse process, but there are singularities, that is, the curvature diverges at \( r = 0 \).
- These singularities lead to the incompleteness of spacetime geodesics, meaning that the paths of some photons or particles will terminate at the singularities within a finite time.

2. **New physical effects beyond General Relativity**:
- New physical theories (such as quantum gravity) may affect the structure of black - hole spacetime, so that singularities can be eliminated or shielded.
- The author hopes to improve the classical Vaidya spacetime by introducing some new physical principles, making it more in line with the expectations of new physical theories.

3. **Future completeness of geodesics**:
- The author hopes to find a method so that the improved spacetime has no singularities and all geodesics are future - complete, that is, they will not terminate within a finite time.

4. **Violation of energy conditions**:
- The improved spacetime may violate the Null Energy Condition (NEC) in a certain finite region inside the event horizon, which indicates that there may be some form of new physical effect.

### Solutions

To achieve the above goals, the author adopts the following methods:

- **Principled - parameterized method**:
- By upgrading the classical Vaidya spacetime metric, introducing a new physical scale \( r_{\text{NP}} \), and ensuring that the improved spacetime satisfies four principles: locality, simplicity, regularity, and the Newtonian limit.

- **Time - dependent gravitational collapse**:
- Generalize the improvement method of static black - hole spacetime to time - dependent spacetime describing gravitational collapse, especially improve the Vaidya spacetime.

- **Verify geodesic behavior**:
- Study the behavior of null geodesics in the improved spacetime and find that these geodesics can be future - complete, which means they will not terminate at singularities.

- **Analysis of energy conditions**:
- It is found that the improved spacetime violates the null energy condition in a certain finite region inside the event horizon, but this does not affect external observers because these regions are shielded.

### Conclusions

Through the above methods, the author successfully constructs an improved Vaidya spacetime model, which not only eliminates singularities but also makes geodesics future - complete. In addition, the improved spacetime violates the null energy condition in some regions, but these regions are invisible to external observers, thus providing a possible mechanism to explain new physical effects in gravitational collapse.

### Related formulas

- The classical metric of Vaidya spacetime:
\[
ds^2_{\text{EF}}=-f[v]dv^2 + 2dvdr + r^2d\Omega^2,\quad f[v]=1-\frac{2G_0m[v]}{r}
\]
where \( G_0 \) is the Newtonian gravitational constant and \( m[v] \) is a time - varying mass function.

- The improved mass function:
\[
m[v]\to m_{\text{NP}}[x^\mu]
\]
where \( m_{\text{NP}}[x^\mu] \) is a function depending on spacetime coordinates, representing the influence of new physical effects.

- The Null Energy Condition (NEC):
\[
\varepsilon=T_{\mu\nu}k^\mu k^\nu\geq0
\]