Abstract:We propose an original technique for the HF radar estimation of the main sea state parameters by exploiting the amplitude modulation of the radar signal time series. While the classical method for ocean wave measurement is based on the second-order ocean Doppler spectrum, this alternative approach makes use of the dominant first-order Bragg echo in the radar signal, which has a larger signal-to-noise ratio and allows for a farther spatial coverage. We apply this method to a yearly set of HF radar data in the vicinity of Toulon (Mediterranean coast of France) and compare it with the classical second-order method, where we use a nearby buoy record as ground truth. The Doppler spectrum-based method is slightly more accurate in estimating the significant wave height and the mean period at a short distance but the temporal approach allows for a significant increase in range and better captures the variability of wave parameters over time.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to use high - frequency radar (HF radar) to estimate ocean wave parameters more accurately, especially at longer distances. Traditional methods rely on the second - order Doppler spectrum, but this method has a low signal - to - noise ratio at long distances, which limits its application range. Therefore, the paper proposes a new method, that is, using the amplitude modulation characteristics of the radar signal time series to estimate the main sea state parameters, especially the significant wave height (Hs) and the peak period (Tp). This method is based on the first - order Bragg echo and has a higher signal - to - noise ratio and a wider spatial coverage. ### Specific problem description 1. **Limitations of traditional methods**: - Traditional methods are based on the second - order Doppler spectrum (SODS) and are used to estimate the significant wave height (Hs) and the peak period (Tp). - The SODS method is relatively accurate at short distances, but at long distances, due to the decrease in the signal - to - noise ratio of the second - order Doppler spectrum, the estimation accuracy decreases and it may even be unable to perform effective estimation. 2. **Advantages of the new method**: - The new method uses the first - order Bragg echo (FOBP) and estimates wave parameters by analyzing the amplitude modulation characteristics of the radar signal time series. - The FOBP method has a higher signal - to - noise ratio and can provide effective wave parameter estimation at longer distances. - This method does not require complex Doppler processing or identification of second - order contributions, simplifying the calculation process. ### Main objectives of the paper 1. **Verify the performance of traditional methods**: - Use a one - year data set to test the performance of the Barrick method (based on SODS) and evaluate the sensitivity of its accuracy to some adjustment parameters. - Propose a clear empirical standard to distinguish between the first - order and second - order Doppler spectra. 2. **Test the performance of the new method**: - Evaluate the performance of the new method (FOBP) based on the statistical characteristics of the radar signal time series at different distances. - Compare the accuracy and stability of the two methods at different distances, especially their performance at long distances. ### Conclusion By comparing the experimental data and the results of the numerical model, the paper verifies the advantages of the new method in estimating wave parameters at long distances. Specifically: - At a short distance (12 km), the estimation results of the SODS method are highly correlated with the buoy measurement data, but at medium distances (30 km) and long distances (52.5 km), the signal - to - noise ratio of the SODS method decreases, resulting in an increase in the estimation error. - In contrast, the FOBP method still maintains good stability and accuracy at long distances and can better capture the time - variation of wave parameters. In summary, this paper aims to propose an improved high - frequency radar wave parameter estimation method to overcome the limitations of traditional methods in long - distance applications.

HF radar estimation of ocean wave parameters: second-order Doppler spectrum versus Bragg wave modulation approach

Improved calculation of the second-order ocean Doppler spectrum for sea state inversion

Wave Height Estimation Based on the Phase Time Series of Millimeter-Wave Radar

Ocean Wave Parameters and Nondirectional Spectrum Measurements Using Multifrequency HF Radar

Waves from compact SeaSonde® High Frequency radars in the southeastern Bay of Biscay: measurement performance under different noise and wind conditions

Estimation of the Wind Field with a Single High-Frequency Radar

Doppler Frequency Components Estimation From Range-Doppler Spectrum Using Shipboard Coherent Microwave Radar

Ocean Surface Current Measurement with High-Frequency Hybrid Sky–surface Wave Radar

High-Frequency Radar observation of strong and contrasted currents: the Alderney race paradigm

S-Band Doppler Wave Radar System

Ocean Wave Measurement Using Short-Range K-Band Narrow Beam Continuous Wave Radar

Wave Parameter Inversion with Coherent Microwave Radar Using Spectral Proper Orthogonal Decomposition

A New Method to Suppress Non-Wave Components in Sea Echoes of Coherent Microwave Radar Based on Radon Transform and Fourier Transform

Inversion of Wave Parameters with Shore-Based Coherent S-Band Radar Using Quasi-Binary Variational Mode Decomposition

Significant Wave Height Retrieved From Coherent X-Band Radar: A Physics-Based Approach

Rapid wavelet-based bathymetry inversion method for nearshore X-band radars

Investigation on the Utilization of Millimeter-Wave Radars for Ocean Wave Monitoring

Validation of wave radar measurements from the TetraSpar Demonstrator floating wind turbine

Coast–Ship Bistatic HF Surface Wave Radar: Simulation Analysis and Experimental Verification

Improved estimation of the directional wave spectrum from marine radar images by employing a directional modulation transfer function (MTF)

Wave Measurements From Radar Tide Gauges