ITRUSST Consensus on Biophysical Safety for Transcranial Ultrasonic Stimulation
Jean-Francois Aubry,David Attali,Mark Schafer,Elsa Fouragnan,Charles Caskey,Robert Chen,Ghazaleh Darmani,Ellen J. Bubrick,Jérôme Sallet,Christopher Butler,Charlotte Stagg,Miriam Klein-Flügge,Seung-Schik Yoo,Brad Treeby,Lennart Verhagen,Kim Butts Pauly
2024-07-13
Abstract:Transcranial ultrasonic stimulation (TUS) is an emerging technology for non-invasive brain stimulation. In a series of meetings, the International Consortium for Transcranial Ultrasonic Stimulation Safety and Standards (ITRUSST) has established expert consensus on considerations for the biophysical safety of TUS, drawing upon the relevant diagnostic ultrasound literature and regulations. This report reflects a consensus expert opinion and can inform but not replace regulatory guidelines or official international standards. Their establishment by international and national commissions will follow expert consensus. Similarly, this consensus will inform but not replace ethical evaluation, which will consider aspects beyond biophysical safety relevant to burden, risk, and benefit, such as physiological effects and disease-specific interactions. Here, we assume the application of TUS to persons who are not at risk for thermal or mechanical damage, and without ultrasound contrast agents. In this context, we present a concise yet comprehensive set of levels for a nonsignificant risk of TUS application. For mechanical effects, it is safe if the mechanical index (MI) or the mechanical index for transcranial application (MItc) does not exceed 1.9. For thermal effects, it is safe if any of the following three levels are met: a temperature rise less than 2 C, a thermal dose less than 0.25 CEM43, or specific values of the thermal index (TI) for a given exposure time. We review literature relevant to our considerations and discuss limitations and future developments of our approach.
Biological Physics,Medical Physics