An Evaluation of Immersive Infographics for News Reporting: Quantifying the Effect of Mobile AR Concrete Scales Infographics on Volume Understanding

Mariane Giambastiani,Jorge Wagner,Carla M. Dal Sasso Freitas,Luciana Nedel
2024-07-10
Abstract:Augmented Reality (AR) allows us to represent information in the user's own environment and, therefore, convey a visceral feeling of its true physical scale. Journalists increasingly leverage this opportunity through immersive infographics, an extension of conventional infographics reliant on familiar references to convey volumes, heights, weights, and sizes. Our goal is to measure the contribution of immersive mobile AR concrete scales infographics to the user's understanding of the information scale. We focus on infographics powered by tablet-based mobile AR, given its current much more widespread use for news consumption compared to headset-based AR. We designed and implemented a study apparatus containing three alternative representation methods (textual analogies, image infographic, and AR infographic) for three different pieces of news with different characteristics and scales. In a controlled user study, we asked 26 participants to represent the expected volume of the information in the real world with the help of an AR mobile application. We also compared their subjective feelings when interacting with the different representations. While both image and AR infographics led to significantly better comprehension than textual analogies alone across different kinds of news, AR infographics led, on average, to a 31.8% smaller volume estimation error than static ones. Our findings indicate that mobile AR concrete scales infographics can contribute to news reporting by increasing readers' abilities to comprehend volume information.
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore the application of augmented reality (AR) immersive infographics in news reporting, especially their role in helping readers understand volumetric information. Specifically, the author hopes to quantify the impact of mobile AR representational - scale infographics on users' understanding of volumetric information through a controlled user study. #### Research Background Infographics are often used in news reporting to convey complex data and information, but traditional infographics may make it difficult for readers to intuitively understand large - quantity or volumetric information. To improve this situation, media companies have begun to utilize augmented reality technology (AR) to provide a more intuitive visual experience through immersive infographics. These immersive infographics can transform abstract data into concrete physical scales, making it easier for readers to understand. #### Research Objectives The author's main objective is to evaluate whether mobile AR representational - scale infographics can better help readers understand volumetric information than traditional static infographics. To this end, they designed and conducted an experiment comparing three different information representation methods: text analogy, static - image infographics, and AR infographics. #### Experimental Design 1. **Research Stimuli**: - Three different types of news reports were selected, involving the amounts of garbage, water, and money. - For each news report, three different representation forms were generated: text description, static - image infographics, and AR infographics. 2. **User Study**: - 26 participants were recruited and asked to estimate the volumes mentioned in the news under different conditions. - Using a mobile AR application, participants were allowed to explore and estimate volumes in the real environment through tablets. - The subjective feelings and volume - estimation errors of participants under different representation methods were compared. #### Main Findings - AR infographics performed best in helping users understand volumetric information, reducing the volume - estimation error by an average of 31.8%. - Image infographics were also significantly better than the traditional method of using only text analogy. - Participants reported higher levels of emotional responses such as attention, sadness, and amazement when using AR infographics. #### Conclusions This study shows that mobile AR representational - scale infographics can significantly improve readers' ability to understand volumetric information and have more emotional impact compared to traditional infographics. This provides new ideas and tools for future news reporting and data visualization. ### Formula Summary This article does not involve complex mathematical formulas and mainly focuses on experimental design and result analysis.