Coordinated JWST Imaging of Three Distance Indicators in a SN Host Galaxy and an Estimate of the TRGB Color Dependence

Taylor J. Hoyt,In Sung Jang,Wendy L. Freedman,Barry F. Madore,Abigail J. Lee,Kayla A. Owens

2024-07-10

Abstract:Boasting a 6.5m mirror in space, JWST can increase by several times the number of supernovae (SNe) to which a redshift-independent distance has been measured with a precision distance indicator (e.g., TRGB or Cepheids); the limited number of such SN calibrators currently dominates the uncertainty budget in distance ladder Hubble constant (H0) experiments. JWST/NIRCAM imaging of the Virgo Cluster galaxy NGC4536 is used here to preview JWST program GO-1995, which aims to measure H0 using three stellar distance indicators (Cepheids, TRGB, JAGB/carbon stars). Each population of distance indicator was here successfully detected -- with sufficiently large number statistics, well-measured fluxes, and characteristic distributions consistent with ingoing expectations -- so as to confirm that we can acquire distances from each method precise to about 0.05mag (statistical uncertainty only). We leverage overlapping HST imaging to identify TRGB stars, cross-match them with the JWST photometry, and present a preliminary constraint on the slope of the TRGB's F115W-(F115W}-F444W) relation equal to -0.99 +/- 0.16 mag/mag. This slope is consistent with prior slope measurements in the similar 2MASS J-band, as well as with predictions from the BASTI isochrone suite. We use the new TRGB slope estimate to flatten the two-dimensional TRGB feature and measure a (blinded) TRGB distance relative to a set of fiducial TRGB colors, intended to represent the absolute fiducial calibrations expected from geometric anchors such as NGC4258 and the Magellanic Clouds. In doing so, we empirically demonstrate that the TRGB can be used as a standardizable candle at the IR wavelengths accessible with JWST.

Astrophysics of Galaxies,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to improve the precision and accuracy of the Hubble constant \(H_0\) measurement by using the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to image three distance indicators (Cepheid variables, tip - of - the - red - giant - branch stars, and carbon - enhanced asymptotic giant - branch stars) in supernova host galaxies. Specifically, the paper focuses on:

1. **Reducing measurement uncertainties**: Current Hubble constant measurements mainly rely on the classical distance ladder method, and the uncertainties of this method mainly come from the limited number of supernova calibrators. Through the high - resolution imaging of JWST, the number of supernovae whose redshift - independent distances can be measured can be significantly increased, thereby reducing these uncertainties.

2. **Verifying the authenticity of the Hubble tension**: In recent years, there has been a significant difference between the Hubble constant directly measured in the local universe and the Hubble constant derived from high - redshift observations (such as cosmic microwave background radiation). This difference is called "Hubble tension". This research aims to evaluate whether this tension really exists by comparing the relative distances of different distance indicators and explore the possible new physical mechanisms behind it.

3. **Determining the color dependence of TRGB**: The tip - of - the - red - giant - branch star (TRGB) is an important distance indicator, especially in the infrared band. However, the relationship between its luminosity and metallicity or color has not been fully determined. Through the observation of the NGC 4536 galaxy, the paper preliminarily estimates the color slope of TRGB in the F115W band and shows how to use this color dependence to improve the precision and accuracy of TRGB distance measurement.

### Key formulas

- **TRGB color slope**:
\[
\text{slope} = - 0.99\pm0.16\,\text{mag/mag}
\]
This slope describes the linear relationship of TRGB stars in the F115W-(F115W - F444W) color.

- **Cepheid period - luminosity relationship**:
\[
M = a\log(P)+b
\]
where \(M\) is the absolute magnitude, \(P\) is the period, and \(a\) and \(b\) are fitting parameters. For the H16 sample, the slope is \(-3.01\pm0.19\) mag/mag; for the R22 sample, the slope is \(-3.15\pm0.21\) mag/mag.

Through these studies, the paper not only improves the understanding of distance indicators but also lays the foundation for more accurate cosmological parameter measurements in the future.