The Pass-through of Retail Crime

Carl Hase,Johannes Kasinger

2024-10-21

Abstract:This paper shows that retailers increase prices in response to organized retail crime. We match store-level crime data to scanner data from the universe of transactions for cannabis retailers in Washington state. Using quasi-experimental variation from robberies and burglaries, we find a 1.5-1.8% price increase at victimized stores and nearby competitors. This rise is not driven by short-to-medium-term demand changes but is consistent with an own-cost shock. Effects are larger for independent stores and less concentrated markets. We estimate that crime imposes a 1% "hidden" unit tax on affected stores, implying $33.9 million additional social costs, primarily borne by consumers.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore the impact of organized retail crime on market prices and its resulting welfare effects. Specifically, by studying criminal behavior in the cannabis retail industry in Washington State, the author analyzes whether retail crime will cause stores to raise prices and evaluates the economic impact of such price increases on consumers and retailers.

#### Main research questions:
1. **The impact of retail crime on prices**: Will retail crime cause stores to increase the prices of goods? If so, what is the magnitude of this price increase?
2. **Welfare effects**: What are the effects of price increases caused by retail crime on consumer surplus, retailer profits, and total social costs?
3. **The impact of market structure**: Are there differences in the impact of retail crime on prices in different types of stores (such as independent stores and chain stores) and under different market concentration levels?

#### Research background:
- **Definition of retail crime**: Organized retail crime usually refers to large - scale theft of retail goods or cash, usually carried out by more than two people and often as part of a criminal enterprise.
- **Research background**: Retail crime is becoming increasingly serious in the United States, especially in the cannabis retail industry, where criminal acts include robbery and theft. These crimes not only bring direct losses to merchants but may also increase security costs and insurance premiums, thus indirectly affecting commodity prices.

#### Research methods:
- **Data sources**: The author used transaction - scanning data of cannabis retailers in Washington State and store - level crime data, covering all upstream and downstream transactions.
- **Quasi - experimental design**: Using the time differences of criminal incidents, a difference - in - differences (DiD) framework was adopted to compare the price changes of victimized stores with those of stores in the unaffected local market.
- **Heterogeneity analysis**: The impact of different store types (such as independent stores and chain stores) and market concentration on price changes was studied.

#### Main findings:
- **Price increase**: Victimized stores increased their prices by approximately 1.8% within four months after the criminal incident, and this increase persisted.
- **Competitor response**: Competitors within 5 miles of the victimized stores also increased their prices by approximately 1.5% two months later.
- **Welfare effects**: The additional social cost caused by retail crime is approximately $33.9 million per year, most of which is borne by consumers.
- **The impact of market structure**: The price increase in independent stores is greater than that in chain stores, and the price increase is more obvious in areas with lower market concentration.

#### Conclusion:
Retail crime not only directly affects the costs of victimized stores but also spreads to consumers and other competitors through price increases, bringing significant social costs. Therefore, it is crucial to understand and address the impact of retail crime on the market and consumers.