Minimum-regret hydrogen supply chain strategies to foster the energy transition of European hard-to-abate industries

Alissa Ganter,Paolo Gabrielli,Hanne Goericke,Giovanni Sansavini

2024-07-08

Abstract:Low-carbon hydrogen (H2) is envisioned to play a central role in decarbonizing European hard-to-abate industries, such as refineries, ammonia, methanol, steel, and cement. To enable its widespread use, H2 supply chain (HSC) infrastructure is required. Mature and economically viable low-carbon H2 production pathways include steam methane reforming (SMR) of natural gas coupled with carbon dioxide capture and storage (CCS), water-electrolysis from renewable electricity, biomethane reforming, and biomass gasification. However, uncertainties surrounding demand and feedstock availabilities hamper their proliferation. Here, we investigate the impact of uncertainty in H2 demand and biomass availability on the optimal HSC design. The HSC is modeled as a network of H2 production and consumption sites that are interconnected with H2 and biomass transport technologies. A CCS supply chain is modeled alongside the HSC. The cost-optimal HSC design is determined based on a linear optimization problem that considers a regional resolution and a multi-year time horizon (2022-2050). We adopt a scenario-based uncertainty quantification approach and define discrete H2 demand and biomass availability scenarios. Applying a minimum-regret strategy, we show that sufficiently large low-carbon H2 production capacities (about 9.6 Mt/a by 2030) are essential to flexibly scale up HSCs and accommodate H2 demands of up to 35 Mt/a by 2050. While biomass-based H2 production emerges as the most cost-efficient low-carbon H2 production pathway, investments are not recommended unless the availability of biomass feedstocks is guaranteed. Instead, investments in SMR-CCS and electrolysis often offer greater flexibility. In addition, we highlight the importance of CCS infrastructure, which is required across scenarios.

Physics and Society,Emerging Technologies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of uncertainty in the design of low-carbon hydrogen supply chains for hard-to-abate sectors in Europe (such as refining, ammonia, methanol, steel, and cement). Specifically, the paper focuses on how uncertainties in future hydrogen demand and biomass supply affect the design and deployment of hydrogen supply chains (HSC). To address these uncertainties, the paper adopts a minimum-regret strategy, determining the cost-optimal design of low-carbon hydrogen supply chains through a linear optimization model and evaluating performance under different scenarios.

### Main Research Questions:
1. **How do uncertainties in future hydrogen demand and biomass supply affect the optimal design and deployment of hydrogen supply chains and CO₂ infrastructure?**
2. **Which hydrogen production technologies, feedstocks, and energy sources are consistently used in the optimal future hydrogen supply chain design?**

### Research Background:
- **Low-carbon hydrogen** (H₂) is considered a key means to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in Europe's hard-to-abate sectors.
- **Existing hydrogen demand**: Currently, Europe consumes about 8.2 million tons of hydrogen annually, mainly for chemical production and refining.
- **Uncertainty in future demand**: Government agencies and energy consulting firms have forecasted hydrogen demand for 2030 and 2050, but these forecasts vary widely, ranging from 2.4 million tons to 40 million tons.
- **Uncertainty in biomass supply**: The collection and transportation of biomass face various challenges, including inadequate infrastructure and competition with other industries.

### Research Methods:
- **System description**: The hydrogen supply chain is modeled as a network, with nodes representing hydrogen production and consumption locations, and edges representing hydrogen and biomass transportation technologies.
- **Quantification of uncertainty**: Different scenarios of hydrogen demand and biomass supply are defined, using a scenario-based uncertainty analysis method.
- **Optimization model**: A linear optimization model is used to determine the cost-optimal design of low-carbon hydrogen supply chains, considering regional spatial resolution and multiple time scales from 2022 to 2050.
- **Minimum-regret strategy**: By comparing performance under different scenarios, the design with the lowest cost in the worst-case scenario is determined.

### Main Findings:
- **Hydrogen production capacity**: By 2030, planning for a sufficiently large low-carbon hydrogen production capacity (about 9.6 million tons/year) is necessary to flexibly expand the hydrogen supply chain to meet the demand of up to 35 million tons/year by 2050.
- **Biomass-based hydrogen production**: Although biomass-based hydrogen production is the most cost-effective low-carbon hydrogen production technology, it is not recommended to invest in it under uncertain biomass supply conditions.
- **SMR-CCS and electrolyzers**: Investing in SMR-CCS and electrolyzers provides greater flexibility under uncertain biomass supply conditions.
- **CO₂ capture, transport, and storage infrastructure**: These infrastructures are key to achieving the 2050 net-zero emission target in all scenarios.

### Conclusion:
The paper provides cost-optimal hydrogen supply chain design recommendations to address uncertainties in future hydrogen demand and biomass supply through a minimum-regret strategy. These findings are of significant reference value for policymakers and industry in planning and investing in low-carbon hydrogen infrastructure.