Bridging-Induced Phase Separation and Loop Extrusion Drive Noise in Chromatin Transcription

Michael Chiang,Cleis Battaglia,Giada Forte,Chris A. Brackley,Nick Gilbert,Davide Marenduzzo

2024-07-06

Abstract:Transcriptional noise, or heterogeneity, is important in cellular development and in disease. The molecular mechanisms driving it are, however, elusive and ill-understood. Here, we use computer simulations to explore the role of 3D chromatin structure in driving transcriptional noise. We study a simple polymer model where proteins - modeling complexes of transcription factors and polymerases - bind multivalently to transcription units - modeling regulatory elements such as promoters and enhancers. We also include cohesin-like factors which extrude chromatin loops that are important for the physiological folding of chromosomes. We find that transcription factor binding creates spatiotemporal patterning and a highly variable correlation time in transcriptional dynamics, providing a mechanism for intrinsic noise within a single cell. Instead, loop extrusion contributes to extrinsic noise, as the stochastic nature of this process leads to different networks of cohesin loops in different cells in our simulations. Our results could be tested with single-cell experiments and provide a pathway to understanding the principles underlying transcriptional plasticity in vivo.

Biological Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the noise in chromatin transcription (i.e., heterogeneity in gene expression between cells) and its molecular mechanism. The study analyzed how the 3D chromatin structure affects transcriptional noise through computer simulations. The authors discovered that bridging-induced phase separation (BIPS) leads to multivalent binding of transcription factors on DNA regulatory elements, forming spatiotemporal patterns and increasing the correlation time of transcription dynamics, thus generating intrinsic noise. On the other hand, loop extrusion (LE) is executed by structural maintenance of chromosome (SMC) complexes like cohesin, which, due to its randomness, results in distinct cohesin loop networks in different cells, increasing extrinsic noise.

In the paper, researchers used a simple polymer model to simulate the multivalent binding of proteins (representing transcription factors and RNA polymerase complex) with transcription units (such as promoters and enhancers) and considered factors similar to cohesin that form chromatin loops during loop extrusion. The study found that the binding of transcription factors produces nontrivial dynamic correlations, and reducing the valency of bound proteins can decrease noise. Additionally, the randomness of loop extrusion leads to diverse interaction networks between cells, increasing the diversity of transcriptional outputs.

The paper also suggests that intrinsic noise is related to the spatiotemporal clustering of transcription units, while extrinsic noise is associated with heterogeneity in cohesin loop formation between cells. By manipulating the spacing between transcription units and simulating the number and size of cohesin loops, the researchers demonstrated how these two processes interact to generate transcriptional noise. Lastly, they propose that single-cell experiments can validate these theoretical predictions and provide insights into the principles of transcriptional plasticity in living organisms.