A Proposal for a FAIR Management of 3D Data in Cultural Heritage: The Aldrovandi Digital Twin Case

Sebastian Barzaghi,Alice Bordignon,Bianca Gualandi,Ivan Heibi,Arcangelo Massari,Arianna Moretti,Silvio Peroni,Giulia Renda
2024-09-14
Abstract:In this article we analyse 3D models of cultural heritage with the aim of answering three main questions: what processes can be put in place to create a FAIR-by-design digital twin of a temporary exhibition? What are the main challenges in applying FAIR principles to 3D data in cultural heritage studies and how are they different from other types of data (e.g. images) from a data management perspective? We begin with a comprehensive literature review touching on: FAIR principles applied to cultural heritage data; representation models; both Object Provenance Information (OPI) and Metadata Record Provenance Information (MRPI), respectively meant as, on the one hand, the detailed history and origin of an object, and - on the other hand - the detailed history and origin of the metadata itself, which describes the primary object (whether physical or digital); 3D models as cultural heritage research data and their creation, selection, publication, archival and preservation. We then describe the process of creating the Aldrovandi Digital Twin, by collecting, storing and modelling data about cultural heritage objects and processes. We detail the many steps from the acquisition of the Digital Cultural Heritage Objects (DCHO), through to the upload of the optimised DCHO onto a web-based framework (ATON), with a focus on open technologies and standards for interoperability and preservation. Using the FAIR Principles for Heritage Library, Archive and Museum Collections as a framework, we look in detail at how the Digital Twin implements FAIR principles at the object and metadata level. We then describe the main challenges we encountered and we summarise what seem to be the peculiarities of 3D cultural heritage data and the possible directions for further research in this field.
Digital Libraries,Social and Information Networks
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are: 1. **How to create a digital twin that follows the FAIR principles**: Specifically, the paper explores what measures can be taken to ensure the findability, accessibility, interoperability, and reusability of data during the creation of a digital twin for a temporary exhibition. This involves the management of 3D models and how to consider the application of the FAIR principles at the design stage. 2. **What are the main challenges in applying the FAIR principles to 3D data of cultural heritage**: The paper analyzes the specific challenges encountered when applying the FAIR principles in cultural heritage research and how these challenges differ from those when dealing with other types of data (such as images). For example, the complexity and format diversity of 3D data, as well as the cost and technical requirements for storing and managing this data. 3. **How do 3D models differ from traditional digital images from the perspective of data management**: The paper discusses the unique nature of 3D models as data in cultural heritage research, including the processes of their creation, selection, publication, archiving, and preservation. These differences are manifested not only at the technical level but also in data management and long - term preservation strategies. By solving these problems, the paper aims to provide practical guidance for researchers in the field of cultural heritage to promote more effective use and sharing of 3D data.