Abstract:Background: There are many problems with fitness trackers, such as device usability, which limit their large-scale application, and relevant studies are limited in terms of their sample size and evaluation methods. The purpose of the study was to evaluate the perceived usability of various mainstream fitness trackers on the market, and to learn about user feedback on feature preferences for each device. Methods: Trial use of seven mainstream fitness trackers (two smart watches and five smart wristbands) followed by a survey study were applied. The questionnaire was specifically developed for this study, which included two parts (user preferences and device usability in five dimensions). We recruited users to test the devices for at least 30 days and asked experienced users to provide feedback in order to evaluate each device, including the rating and user preference of each device. Results: We received 388 valid questionnaires, in which users rated their responses on a five-point Likert scale. (1) User preference: the average user satisfaction was 3.50-3.86 (points), and the rating for willingness to buy averaged between 3.36 and 3.59. More users were willing to wear (58.3-81.3%) and purchase (56.8-83.0%) the devices than were not. The top three general feature preferences were daily activity tracking, heart health monitoring, and professional fitness tracking. The top three health-related feature preferences were heart rate monitoring, daily pedometer, and professional fitness tracking. (2) Usability evaluation: product design was rated from 3.57 to 4.00; durability, 3.63-4.26; ease of use, 3.70-3.90; added features, 3.30-3.83; and user-rated accuracy, 3.44-3.78. A significant difference was observed in the rating of product design and durability among the different devices (p < 0.05) score. Conclusions: Users generally had positive subjective intent regarding fitness trackers but were less satisfied with their cost effectiveness. The users preferred health related features such as heart health monitoring, and professional fitness tracking. The rating of most of the current mainstream fitness trackers was fair with some significant differences among the devices. Thus, further improvement is needed.

A Study on Activity Visualization for Smart Watches

Visualizing information on watch faces: A survey with smartwatch users

Visualizing Information on Smartwatch Faces: A Review and Design Space

Fuzzy Theory Analysis on Imagery Modeling of Wearable Bracelet in the Urbanian Health Management

The effect of smartwatch head shape on visual imagery perception

A Survey of Patterns for Adapting Smartphone App UIs to Smart Watches.

A Qualitative Exploration of a User-Centered Model for Smartwatch Comfort Using Grounded Theory

Playing with Multiple Wearable Devices: Exploring the Influence of Display, Motion and Gender

Attention, Comprehension, Execution

Making sense of health data of wearables: designing information displays for older wearable users

Adapting the Navigation Interface of Smart Watches to User Movements

Longitudinal Analysis of Heart Rate and Physical Activity Collected from Smartwatches

Reflections on Visualization in Motion for Fitness Trackers

A Simulated Graphical Interface for Integrating Patient-Generated Health Data From Smartwatches With Electronic Health Records: Usability Study

A study on the Design Factors of Wearable Watches for the China Elderly on User Perception and Willingness to Use

Monitoring Student Activities with Smartwatches: On the Academic Performance Enhancement

“Just Like Blooming Fireworks, And Match With Function Perfectly”: Explore and Evaluate User-Defined One-Handed Gestures of Smartwatch

A Personal Visual Analytics on Smartphone Usage Data.

The Value of Smartwatches in the Health Care Sector for Monitoring, Nudging, and Predicting: Viewpoint on 25 Years of Research

Perceived user preferences and usability evaluation of mainstream wearable devices for health monitoring

Initial Development of User-Based Quality Evaluation Questionnaire of Smartwatch Technology for Applying to Healthcare