Enantiospecificity in NMR Enabled by Chirality-Induced Spin Selectivity

T. Georgiou,J.L. Palma,V. Mujica,S. Varela,M. Galante,V. Santamarıa Garcıa,L. Mboning,R.N. Schwartz,G. Cuniberti,L.-S. Bouchard
2024-07-03
Abstract:Spin polarization in chiral molecules is a magnetic molecular response associated with electron transport and enantioselective bond polarization that occurs even in the absence of an external magnetic field. An unexpected finding by Santos and co-workers reported enantiospecific NMR responses in solid-state cross-polarization (CP) experiments, suggesting a possible additional contribution to the indirect nuclear spin-spin coupling in chiral molecules induced by bond polarization in the presence of spin-orbit coupling. Herein we provide a theoretical treatment for this phenomenon, presenting an effective spin-Hamiltonian for helical molecules like DNA and density functional theory (DFT) results on amino acids that confirm the dependence of J-couplings on the choice of enantiomer. The connection between nuclear spin dynamics and chirality could offer insights for molecular sensing and quantum information sciences. These results establish NMR as a potential tool for chiral discrimination without external agents.
Soft Condensed Matter,Biological Physics,Chemical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is **how to directly distinguish chiral molecules by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) technology without external reagents or indirect methods**. Specifically, the paper explores the influence of the chiral - induced spin - selectivity (CISS) effect on nuclear spin - spin coupling and whether this effect can be used to achieve chiral - specific responses in solid - state NMR experiments. ### Background and Problems of the Paper 1. **Significance of Chirality**: - Chirality is a fundamental structural property in chemical and biological processes, and the study of chiral molecules is of great significance in fields such as asymmetric synthesis and drug design. - Traditional NMR techniques cannot distinguish enantiomers in an achiral environment because their NMR spectra are the same. 2. **Limitations of Existing Methods**: - Currently, there are mainly three methods for distinguishing chiral molecules by NMR: using chiral derivatizing agents (CDAs), chiral solvents, and chiral lanthanide shift reagents. All of these methods have certain limitations, mainly relying on external reagents and being complex to operate. 3. **CISS Effect**: - The CISS effect refers to that when electrons are transmitted in chiral molecules, due to the spin - orbit coupling (SOC) effect, they will experience a momentum - dependent effective magnetic field, resulting in spin selectivity and polarization. - This effect not only affects electron transmission but also may affect nuclear spin - spin coupling, thus providing a new way to distinguish chiral molecules. ### Research Objectives - **Theoretical Framework**: The paper proposes a theoretical framework to explain the mechanism of nuclear spin - spin coupling in chiral molecules. Specifically, through electron - nuclear spin interactions (such as electron - nuclear dipole - dipole interaction and Fermi contact interaction), the electron wave function in chiral molecules can mediate the indirect coupling between nuclear spins. - **Experimental Verification**: The paper verifies this theoretical framework through density functional theory (DFT) calculations and experimental data. The results show that there are significant differences in J - coupling values between different enantiomers, which provides a theoretical basis for NMR technology to directly distinguish chiral molecules. ### Main Findings - **Chirality - Dependent Nuclear Spin - Spin Coupling**: The paper finds that the electron wave function in chiral molecules is chirality - dependent due to the CISS effect, and this dependence can be transferred to nuclear spins through electron - nuclear spin interactions, resulting in different nuclear spin - spin coupling strengths between different enantiomers. - **Experimental Results**: Through DFT calculations and solid - state NMR experiments, the paper shows that there are significant differences in J - coupling values between different amino acid enantiomers, further supporting the chirality - dependent nuclear spin - spin coupling mechanism. ### Significance and Applications - **New Applications of NMR Technology**: This research opens up new ways for the application of NMR technology in chiral molecule analysis, especially for those analysis tasks requiring high sensitivity and high resolution. - **Basic Scientific Research**: The research results deepen the understanding of electron transmission and nuclear spin dynamics in chiral molecules and provide a new perspective for future basic scientific research. In conclusion, this paper explores the mechanism of nuclear spin - spin coupling in chiral molecules by combining theoretical and experimental methods and proposes the possibility of using NMR technology to directly distinguish chiral molecules. This finding not only has important scientific significance but also provides new ideas for practical applications.