Daniele Guerci,Giorgio Sangiovanni,Andrew J. Millis,Michele Fabrizio
Abstract:We show that in models with the Hatsugai-Kohmoto type of interaction that is local in momentum space thus infinite-range in real space, Kubo formulas neither reproduce the correct thermodynamic susceptibilities, nor yield sensible transport coefficients. Using Kohn's trick to differentiate between metals and insulators by threading a flux in a torus geometry, we uncover the striking property that Hatsugai-Kohmoto models with an interaction-induced gap in the spectrum sustain a current that grows as the linear size at any non-zero flux and which can be either diamagnetic or paramagnetic.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in models with Hatsugai - Kohmoto (HK) - type interactions, the Kubo formula can neither reproduce the correct thermodynamic susceptibility nor give reasonable transport coefficients. Specifically, the paper points out that in these models, due to the locality of the HK interaction in momentum space (corresponding to an infinite range in real space), it leads to non - physical properties of the response function in the long - wave limit. For example, the current response will grow linearly with the linear size of the system at any non - zero flux and can be paramagnetic or diamagnetic.
### Specific Problems and Background
1. **Characteristics of the HK Model**:
- The HK model is a special variant of the Hubbard model, and its interaction term \( U_{\text{HK}} \) is local in momentum space but has an infinite range in real space.
- This model can be solved analytically and exhibits unique physical properties when the interaction - induced energy gap opens.
2. **Problems with the Kubo Formula**:
- In traditional models, the Kubo formula is used to calculate thermodynamic susceptibility and transport coefficients.
- However, in the HK model, due to the special nature of the interaction, the Kubo formula fails to correctly describe these physical quantities.
3. **Application of the Kohn Criterion**:
- The paper applies the method proposed by Kohn in 1964 to distinguish between metals and insulators by introducing flux in toroidal geometry to detect the system's response.
- The results show that even when there is an energy gap in the single - particle energy spectrum, the HK model still exhibits metallic characteristics, that is, it has a non - zero Drude weight.
### Main Findings
- **Singular Behavior of the Current Response**:
- In the HK model, the current response is divergent in the long - wave limit, which is inconsistent with the traditional insulator behavior.
- This singular behavior is caused by the infinite - range nature of the HK interaction, especially the contribution of long - distance pair - hopping processes.
- **Abnormality of the Drude Weight**:
- Even when there is an energy gap in the single - particle energy spectrum, the Drude weight of the HK model is not zero, indicating that the system is sensitive to boundary conditions, similar to the behavior of metals.
- **Influence of Topological Properties**:
- The paper also discusses the topological properties of the HK model, pointing out that although the quantum spin Hall conductivity can be calculated correctly, there are some non - physical transport properties, such as infinite bulk conductivity and the inability to define the concept of boundaries.
### Conclusion
The paper emphasizes that when dealing with models with HK - type interactions, special caution is required in using the Kubo formula and other traditional methods. The infinite - range interactions in these models lead to some non - physical properties that may not occur in actual materials. Therefore, new theoretical tools and methods need to be developed when studying these models.