Practical Power System Inertia Monitoring Based on Pumped Storage Hydropower Operation Signature

Hongyu Li,Chang Chen,Mark Baldwin,Shutang You,Wenpeng Yu,Lin Zhu,Yilu Liu

2024-07-02

Abstract:This paper proposes a practical method to monitor power system inertia using Pumped Storage Hydropower (PSH) switching-off events. This approach offers real-time system-level inertia estimation with minimal expenses, no disruption, and the inclusion of behind-the-meter inertia. First, accurate inertia estimation is achieved through improved RoCoF calculation that accounts for pre-event RoCoF, reducing common random frequency fluctuations in practice. Second, PSH field data is analyzed, highlighting the benefits of using switching-off events for grid inertia estimation. Third, an event detection trigger is designed to capture pump switching-off events based on local and system features. Fourth, the method is validated on the U.S. Eastern Interconnection model with over 60,000 buses, demonstrating very high accuracy (3%-5% error rate). Finally, it is applied to the U.S. Western Interconnection, with field validation showing a 9.9% average absolute error rate. Despite challenges in practical power system inertia estimation, this method enhances decision-making for power grid reliability and efficiency, addressing challenges posed by renewable energy integration.

Systems and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the challenge of real-time monitoring of system inertia in modern power systems. With the increasing penetration of renewable energy, the reduction of traditional generators leads to a decline in system inertia, which poses a greater risk to the stability of the power system. Therefore, accurately estimating system inertia in real-time becomes particularly important to ensure the reliability and efficiency of the power grid.

Existing inertia estimation methods have some limitations:
1. **Summation of online generator inertia based on scheduling**: It may overlook inertia from inverter-based resources (IBRs) and behind-the-meter resources (such as load inertia and synthetic inertia from renewable energy).
2. **Probe signal-based methods**: Require additional investment to generate probe signals, which is costly.
3. **Ambient signal-based methods**: Rely on the frequency noise of the power system, and the accuracy is affected by the uncertainty of noise sources.
4. **Event-driven methods**: Although more accurate, they are limited by the insufficient number of generator trip events, usually require offline analysis, and lack confirmed event information.

To address these challenges, this paper proposes a novel practical method for system inertia estimation at the interconnected grid level based on Pumped Storage Hydropower (PSH) pump trip events. This method utilizes the constant large disturbance in PSH pump trip events, significantly improving the accuracy of inertia estimation. Specifically, this method has the following advantages:
1. **Non-intrusive**: Utilizes existing PSH event characteristics without the need for additional expensive power regulators, avoiding intrusive synthetic signals.
2. **Cost-effective**: Does not require real-time power measurement and can obtain constant power step signals through public pump unit capacity or historical data, compatible with low-cost sensors.
3. **High accuracy**: Measures frequency response to reflect the impact of all types of inertia and reduces the influence of background random frequency fluctuations through an improved RoCoF calculation.

The main contributions of this method include:
1. Proposing a novel inertia monitoring method based on PSH pump trip events and analyzing field data to highlight its practical application advantages.
2. Developing an improved RoCoF algorithm that excludes common random frequency fluctuations.
3. Designing an online event trigger that efficiently captures real-time PSH pump trip events using local features such as frequency spikes and voltage steps.
4. Validating the method on the Eastern Interconnection model in the United States and applying it in the Western Interconnection, showing high accuracy.

In summary, this paper aims to provide a practical, efficient, and accurate method for power system inertia monitoring to address the challenges brought by renewable energy integration and improve the reliability and efficiency of the power system.