Mathematical modelling and uncertainty quantification for analysis of biphasic coral reef recovery patterns

David J. Warne,Kerryn Crossman,Grace E. M. Heron,Jesse A. Sharp,Wang Jin,Paul Pao-Yen Wu,Matthew J. Simpson,Kerrie Mengersen,Juan-Carlos Ortiz

2024-06-28

Abstract:Coral reefs are increasingly subjected to major disturbances threatening the health of marine ecosystems. Substantial research underway to develop intervention strategies that assist reefs in recovery from, and resistance to, inevitable future climate and weather extremes. To assess potential benefits of interventions, mechanistic understanding of coral reef recovery and resistance patterns is essential. Recent evidence suggests that more than half of the reefs surveyed across the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) exhibit deviations from standard recovery modelling assumptions when the initial coral cover is low ($\leq 10$\%). New modelling is necessary to account for these observed patterns to better inform management strategies. We consider a new model for reef recovery at the coral cover scale that accounts for biphasic recovery patterns. The model is based on a multispecies Richards' growth model that includes a change point in the recovery patterns. Bayesian inference is applied for uncertainty quantification of key parameters for assessing reef health and recovery patterns. This analysis is applied to benthic survey data from the Australian Institute of Marine Sciences (AIMS). We demonstrate agreement between model predictions and data across every recorded recovery trajectory with at least two years of observations following disturbance events occurring between 1992--2020. This new approach will enable new insights into the biological, ecological and environmental factors that contribute to the duration and severity of biphasic coral recovery patterns across the GBR. These new insights will help to inform managements and monitoring practice to mitigate the impacts of climate change on coral reefs.

Applications,Populations and Evolution

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main focus of this paper is on the biphasic recovery patterns in coral reef restoration processes, which are atypical recovery patterns discovered when coral cover is low (≤10%). It is characterized by a transient period of reduced recovery rate. Existing recovery models are typically based on classic population growth models such as exponential, Gaussian, or logistic growth models, but these models cannot explain this biphasic pattern. In this paper, the authors propose a new biphasic coral recovery model based on a multi-species Richards growth model, which includes a breakpoint to reflect the transition of recovery patterns. By using Bayesian analysis, they quantify the uncertainty of key parameters to assess coral reef health and recovery patterns, and apply this analysis to field survey data from the Australian Institute of Marine Science in the Great Barrier Reef.

The study found that the model predictions aligned with the observed recovery trajectories for at least two years, covering disturbance events from 1992 to 2020. This approach helps reveal biological, ecological, and environmental factors that influence the duration and severity of coral recovery, providing new insights for management strategies addressing the impact of climate warming on coral reefs. The paper also mentions some limitations in meeting the conditions for biphasic pattern analysis, but the new model reduces these limitations, making it possible to consider biphasic recovery effects in a broader range of scenarios.