Abstract:Internet censorship is pervasive, with significant effort dedicated to understanding what is censored, and where. Prior censorship work however have identified significant inconsistencies in their results; experiments show unexplained non-determinism thought to be caused by censor load, end-host geographic diversity, or incomplete censorship -- inconsistencies which impede reliable, repeatable and correct understanding of global censorship. In this work we investigate the extent to which Equal-cost Multi-path (ECMP) routing is the cause for these inconsistencies, developing methods to measure and compensate for them. We find ECMP routing significantly changes observed censorship across protocols, censor mechanisms, and in 17 countries. We identify that previously observed non-determinism or regional variations are attributable to measurements between fixed end-hosts taking different routes based on Flow-ID; i.e., choice of intra-subnet source IP or ephemeral source port leads to differences in observed censorship. To achieve this we develop new route-stable censorship measurement methods that allow consistent measurement of DNS, HTTP, and HTTPS censorship. We find ECMP routing yields censorship changes across 42% of IPs and 51% of ASes, but that impact is not uniform. We identify numerous causes of the behavior, ranging from likely failed infrastructure, to routes to the same end-host taking geographically diverse paths which experience differences in censorship en-route. Finally, we explore our results in the context of prior global measurement studies, exploring first the applicability of our findings to prior observed variations, and then demonstrating how specific experiments from two studies could be impacted by, and specific results are explainable by, ECMP routing. Our work points to methods for improving future studies, reducing inconsistencies and increasing repeatability.

Understanding Routing-Induced Censorship Changes Globally

Pathfinder: Exploring Path Diversity for Assessing Internet Censorship Inconsistency

Unveiling Internet Censorship: Analysing the Impact of Nation States' Content Control Efforts on Internet Architecture and Routing Patterns

A Churn for the Better: Localizing Censorship using Network-level Path Churn and Network Tomography

Charting Censorship Resilience and Global Internet Reachability: A Quantitative Approach

Minimizing Wide-Area Performance Disruptions in Inter-Domain Routing

Augmenting Rule-based DNS Censorship Detection at Scale with Machine Learning

Automated Discovery of Internet Censorship by Web Crawling

Measuring Irregular Geographic Exposure on the Internet

A Study on Geographic Properties of Internet Routing

Large-scale Spatiotemporal Characterization of Inconsistencies in the World's Largest Firewall

Quantifying Nations Exposure to Traffic Observation and Selective Tampering

Few Throats to Choke: On the Current Structure of the Internet

Quantifying Path Exploration in the Internet

A Fresh Look at ECN Traversal in the Wild

Impact of International Submarine Cable on Internet Routing.

Detecting Network-based Internet Censorship via Latent Feature Representation Learning

IP Reachability differences: Myths and realities

Analyzing Intercontinental Circuitousness to Improve the Interconnection and Routing for ISPs.

The (thin) Bridges of AS Connectivity: Measuring Dependency using AS Hegemony

Internet Flattening: Monitoring and Analysis of Inter-Domain Routing