Quantitative measurement of cooperative binding in partially dissociated water dimers at the hematite R-cut surface

Paul T. P. Ryan,Panukorn Sombut,Ali Rafsanjani Abbasi,Chunlei Wang,Fulden Eratam,Francesco Goto,Ulrike Diebold,Matthias Meier,David A. Duncan,Gareth S. Parkinson
2024-06-26
Abstract:Water-solid interfaces pervade the natural environment and modern technology. On some surfaces, water-water interactions induce the formation of partially dissociated interfacial layers; understanding why is important to model processes in catalysis or mineralogy. The complexity of the partially dissociated structures often make it difficult to probe them in a quantitative manner. Here, we utilize normal incidence x-ray standing waves (NIXSW) to study the structure of partially dissociated water dimers (H2O-OH) at the Fe2O3(012) surface (also called (1-102) or R-cut surface); a system simple enough to be tractable, yet complex enough to capture the essential physics. We find the H2O and terminal OH groups to be the same height above the surface within experimental error (1.45 +/- 0.04 Angstrom and 1.47 +/- 0.02 Angstrom, respectively), in line with DFT-based calculations that predict comparable Fe-O bond lengths for both water and OH species. This result is understood in the context of cooperative binding, where the formation of the H-bond between adsorbed H2O and OH induces the H2O to bind more strongly, and OH to bind more weakly compared to when these species are isolated on the surface. The surface OH formed by the liberated proton is found to be in plane with a bulk truncated (012) surface (-0.01 +/- 0.02 Angstrom). DFT calculations based on various functionals correctly model the cooperative effect, but overestimate the water-surface interaction.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily focuses on the adsorption behavior of water molecules on a specific surface of hematite (α-Fe2O3), referred to as the "R-cut" or (012) surface, particularly the partially dissociated water dimer structure and its formation mechanism. Specifically, the core issue of the study is to understand and quantify the interactions between water molecules and hydroxyl (OH) groups on this surface, and how these interactions affect the adsorption height and structural stability of the water molecules. The paper employs normal incidence X-ray standing wave (NIXSW) technique to analyze the structure of water-hydroxyl dimers (H2O-OH) formed on the hematite (012) surface. The main findings include: - The heights of H2O and terminal OH (OHt) are almost identical, being 1.45±0.04 Å and 1.47±0.02 Å respectively, indicating that they form similar Fe-O bond lengths with the surface. - Surface OH (OHs), which is formed by proton release, is located almost in the same plane as the surface oxygen atoms (-0.01±0.02 Å). - This phenomenon can be explained by the cooperative binding effect, where the hydrogen bonding between the adsorbed H2O and OH results in a tighter binding of H2O to the surface, while weakening the binding of OH. Through these findings, the paper provides quantitative evidence supporting the importance of the cooperative binding effect in water adsorption on metal oxide surfaces. Additionally, density functional theory (DFT) calculations are consistent with the experimental data, further validating this explanation. In summary, the study addresses the issue of how to experimentally measure and understand the cooperative binding effect in partially dissociated water dimers on metal oxide surfaces, providing important insights for understanding related catalytic processes.