Abstract:We propose semantic entropy probes (SEPs), a cheap and reliable method for uncertainty quantification in Large Language Models (LLMs). Hallucinations, which are plausible-sounding but factually incorrect and arbitrary model generations, present a major challenge to the practical adoption of LLMs. Recent work by Farquhar et al. (2024) proposes semantic entropy (SE), which can detect hallucinations by estimating uncertainty in the space semantic meaning for a set of model generations. However, the 5-to-10-fold increase in computation cost associated with SE computation hinders practical adoption. To address this, we propose SEPs, which directly approximate SE from the hidden states of a single generation. SEPs are simple to train and do not require sampling multiple model generations at test time, reducing the overhead of semantic uncertainty quantification to almost zero. We show that SEPs retain high performance for hallucination detection and generalize better to out-of-distribution data than previous probing methods that directly predict model accuracy. Our results across models and tasks suggest that model hidden states capture SE, and our ablation studies give further insights into the token positions and model layers for which this is the case.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve
This paper aims to address the hallucination problem in large language models (LLMs). Hallucination refers to the phenomenon where the model generates content that sounds plausible but is actually incorrect or arbitrary. Hallucination poses a significant challenge to the practical application of LLMs, especially in high-risk areas such as medicine, journalism, and legal services. Ensuring the safe deployment of LLMs requires reliable detection or mitigation of hallucinations, which is a critical issue.
### Background and Methods
Existing hallucination detection methods typically require multiple samples of the model's output and check whether these samples convey the same meaning. For example, if a model knows the answer, it will consistently provide the same answer; if the model is uncertain, its output may vary. However, this method is computationally expensive because each input query requires generating multiple model responses, usually 5 to 10 times, making practical application difficult.
### Proposed Method
To address this issue, the authors propose Semantic Entropy Probes (SEPs), a low-cost and reliable method for quantifying uncertainty. SEPs achieve this by approximating semantic entropy (SE) directly from a single generated hidden state. Unlike traditional sampling-based methods, SEPs do not require generating multiple samples during testing, thereby reducing the overhead of quantifying semantic uncertainty to almost zero.
### Main Contributions
1. **Proposing SEPs**: SEPs are linear probes trained on the hidden states of LLMs to capture semantic entropy.
2. **Validating the Effectiveness of SEPs**: Research shows that SEPs can successfully extract semantic entropy from a single model-generated hidden state.
3. **Generalization Performance**: Through ablation studies, the authors found that SEPs effectively capture semantic uncertainty across different models, tasks, layers, and token positions.
4. **Hallucination Detection**: SEPs can be used to predict hallucinations and perform better on new tasks than probes directly trained to predict accuracy, establishing a new cost-effective standard for hallucination detection.
### Experimental Results
- **Hidden State Captures Semantic Entropy**: Experiments show that the hidden states of LLMs indeed encode semantic entropy, and SEPs can consistently capture semantic entropy across different models and tasks.
- **Prediction Before Generation**: SEPs can even predict semantic entropy before generating output, further reducing computational costs.
- **Long Generation Tasks**: SEPs effectively capture semantic entropy in long generation tasks, which are more common in practical applications.
- **Counterfactual Intervention Experiments**: Experiments adding context confirm that SEPs can accurately capture changes in semantic entropy rather than relying on spurious correlations.
### Conclusion
SEPs provide a low-cost and reliable method for detecting hallucinations in LLMs, which is crucial for ensuring the safe application of these models in high-risk areas.