Minimal Model for Chirally Induced Spin Selectivity: Chirality, Spin-orbit coupling, Decoherence and Tunneling

Miguel Mena,Solmar Varela,Bertrand Berche,Ernesto Medina

2024-06-19

Abstract:Here we review a universal model for chirally induced spin-selectivity (CISS) as a standalone effect occurring in chiral molecules. We tie together the results of forward scattering in the gas phase to the results for photoelectrons in chiral self-assembled monolayers and the more contemporary results in two terminal transport setups. We discuss the ingredients that are necessarily present in all experiments to date, which we identify as: i) chirality, be it point, helical or configurational, ii) the spin-orbit coupling as the spin active coupling of atomic origin, iii) decoherence as a time-reversal symmetry breaking mechanism that avoids reciprocity relations in the linear regime and finally iv) tunneling that accounts for the magnitude of the spin polarization effect. This proposal does not discard other mechanisms that can yield comparable spin effects related to interactions of the molecule to contacts or substrates that have been proposed but that are less universal or apply to particular situations. Finally, we discuss recent results suggesting CISS as a molecular phenomenon in the real of enantiomer selectivity, coherent electron transfer, and spin effects in chiroptical activity.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to address the issue of chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect and explore its mechanisms at the molecular scale. Specifically, the paper discusses the following points:

1. **Chirality, Spin-Orbit Coupling, Decoherence, and Tunneling**:
- The study finds that chirality, spin-orbit coupling (SO coupling), decoherence, and tunneling are essential factors in the CISS effect. These factors work together to enable chiral molecules to produce significant spin polarization effects.

2. **Consistency of Experimental Results**:
- The paper compares the forward scattering experimental results in the gas phase with the photoelectron results in self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) and finds consistency between these results. Additionally, the latest results in two-terminal transport devices are discussed.

3. **Development of Theoretical Models**:
- A theoretical model incorporating chirality, SO coupling, and decoherence is proposed to explain the CISS effect. This model introduces a third probe to break time-reversal symmetry, thereby avoiding the constraints of the reciprocity theorem and enabling spin polarization in two-terminal devices.

4. **Decoherence as a Mechanism for Breaking Time-Reversal Symmetry**:
- The paper discusses in detail how decoherence acts as a mechanism for breaking time-reversal symmetry, allowing two-terminal devices to produce spin polarization effects. By introducing an additional probe to simulate the decoherence process, time-reversal symmetry can be effectively broken.

5. **Tunneling and Spin Polarization**:
- The phenomenon of spin polarization during tunneling is studied, and a magnetic field is introduced to break time-reversal symmetry, achieving efficient spin polarization. Additionally, the interaction between SO coupling and decoherence and how it affects spin polarization is explored.

In summary, through the study of the CISS effect, the paper proposes a comprehensive theoretical framework that explains the significant spin polarization effects produced by chiral molecules under different experimental conditions and emphasizes the importance of decoherence as a key mechanism.