Advancing Blockchain Scalability: An Introduction to Layer 1 and Layer 2 Solutions

Han Song,Zhongche Qu,Yihao Wei
2024-06-20
Abstract:Bitcoin rise has put blockchain technology into the mainstream, amplifying its potential and broad utility. While Bitcoin has become incredibly famous, its transaction rate has not match such a corresponding increase. It still takes approximately 10 minutes to mine a block and add it to the chain. This limitation highlights the importance of seeking scale-up solutions that solve the low throughput transaction rates. Blockchain's consensus mechanisms make peer-to-peer transactions becomes feasible and effectively eliminate the need for centralized control. However, the decentralized systems also causes a lower speed and throughput compared to centralized networks as we mentioned Bitcoin's block creation rates. Two mainstreams scale-up solutions, Layer 1 scale-up and Layer 2 scale-up have been implemented to address these issues. Layer 1 level scalability enhancements happen at where traditional blockchain operates. This paper provides a deep examination of the components of the Layer 1 protocol and the scale-up methods that directly improve the lower level blockchain. We also address that Layer 1 solutions encounter inherent limitations although improvements were applied due to layer 1 storage costs and latency are high. In addition, we discuss layer 2 protocols, advanced scalability techniques, that elevate blockchain performance by handling transactions off the mainnet. Our findings indicate that Layer 2 protocols, with their various implementations such as rollups and channels, significantly outperform Layer 1 solutions in terms of transaction throughput and efficiency. This paper discusses these Layer 2 scaling methods in detail, aiming to provide readers with a comprehensive understanding of these protocols and the underlying logic that drives their effectiveness.
Cryptography and Security
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the scalability problem in blockchain technology. Specifically, with the popularization of blockchains such as Bitcoin and the increase in trading volume, the problems of low throughput and high latency have become particularly prominent. For example, Bitcoin can only generate a new block every 10 minutes, resulting in a very limited number of transactions processed per second. This inefficient transaction processing speed cannot meet the growing user demands, especially in large - scale applications. For instance, the Ethereum network will experience network congestion, latency and high Gas fees under high - concurrency situations. To address these issues, the paper explores two main scalability solutions: Layer 1 and Layer 2 expansion schemes. ### Layer 1 Expansion Scheme Layer 1 expansion refers to directly improving the underlying blockchain protocol itself to enhance its performance. The paper discusses several methods: - **Increasing Block Size**: Increase the throughput by increasing the number of transactions that each block can contain. - **Improving the Consensus Mechanism**: For example, Ethereum has shifted from Proof of Work (PoW) to Proof of Stake (PoS), thereby improving the efficiency of transaction verification. - **Sharding**: Divide the blockchain into multiple independent parts (shards), so that nodes only need to process the relevant part of the data, thereby reducing the burden on a single node and improving the overall performance. ### Layer 2 Expansion Scheme Layer 2 expansion achieves higher transaction processing capabilities by building an additional layer on top of the existing blockchain. The paper focuses on the following Layer 2 technologies: - **Rollups**: Package a large number of transactions and process them off - chain, and then submit the results to the main chain for verification. Rollups are divided into Optimistic Rollups and Zero - Knowledge Rollups. The former assumes that all transactions are valid and allows challenges within a certain time window; the latter ensures the correctness of state updates by providing proof of validity. - **Channels**: Including Payment Channels and State Channels, which allow users to conduct multiple transactions off - chain and only submit the results to the main chain at the final settlement. - **Sidechains**: Create an independent blockchain running in parallel with the main chain, which can adopt different consensus algorithms and parameter settings to handle more complex computing and storage tasks. Overall, this paper aims to comprehensively analyze and compare these scalability solutions, help readers understand the advantages and limitations of different methods, and thus promote the further development and application of blockchain technology.