Berezinsky Hidden Sources: An Emergent Tension in the High-Energy Neutrino Sky?

Antonio Ambrosone

2024-06-19

Abstract:The IceCube Collaboration has recently reported compelling evidence of high-energy neutrino emission from NGC~1068, and also mild excesses for NGC 4151 and CGCG420-015, local Seyfert galaxies. This has increased the interest along neutrino emission from hot-corona surrounding the super massive black holes of Seyfert Galaxies. In this paper, we revisit phenomenological constraints on the neutrino emission from hot-coronae of seyfert galaxies, using an assumption of equi-ripartition between cosmic-rays and magnetic energy densities. We show that not only these sources are consistent with such an assumption but also that the data point towards low beta plasma parameters inside Seyfert Galaxies. We exploit this finding to constrain the Seyfert diffuse neutrino flux and we obtain that, in order not to overproduce neutrinos, not all the sources can be in an equi-ripartition state. We conclude (along with previous findings) that seyfert galaxies cannot explain the diffuse neutrino spectrum above $\sim 100\, \rm TeV$, allowing space for other astrophysical sources.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the role of Seyfert Galaxies in the high - energy neutrino sky and their relationship with X - ray luminosity. Specifically, the paper explores the following aspects:

1. **Neutrino Emission Mechanism**: The paper re - examines the mechanism of neutrino emission in the hot corona region of Seyfert Galaxies, especially assuming an equi - partition between cosmic - ray (CRs) and magnetic - field energy densities. Whether this assumption can explain the observed neutrino signals and whether these sources conform to this assumption.

2. **Data Consistency**: The paper analyzes four Seyfert Galaxies (NGC 1068, NGC 4151, CGCG 420 - 015 and NGC 3079) that show excessive neutrino signals in IceCube data, and explores whether these sources are consistent with the equi - partition assumption and whether a low β value (i.e., high magnetic - field strength) can better fit the data.

3. **Diffuse Neutrino Spectrum**: The paper further explores the neutrino emission of Seyfert Galaxies in the entire population and calculates their contribution to the diffuse neutrino spectrum. The study finds that if all Seyfert Galaxies are in an equi - partition state, the diffuse neutrino flux may be over - estimated in the 1 - 10 TeV energy range, potentially contradicting IceCube observations.

4. **Other Astrophysical Sources**: The paper discusses the role of Seyfert Galaxies in the high - energy neutrino sky, pointing out that these galaxies may not be able to fully explain the diffuse neutrino spectrum above 100 TeV, so other astrophysical sources such as blazars or starburst galaxies need to be considered.

### Main Conclusions
- **Consistency of the Equi - partition Assumption**: The four Seyfert Galaxies with observed excessive neutrino signals are consistent with the equi - partition assumption, but the required β value is low (β ≲ 1), indicating that these sources carry a relatively high amount of cosmic - ray energy inside.
- **Over - Estimation of the Diffuse Neutrino Spectrum**: If it is assumed that all Seyfert Galaxies are in an equi - partition state, the diffuse neutrino flux may be over - estimated in the 1 - 10 TeV energy range, which contradicts IceCube observations.
- **Necessity of Other Sources**: Seyfert Galaxies may not be able to fully explain the diffuse neutrino spectrum above 100 TeV, and the contributions of other astrophysical sources need to be considered.

### Future Prospects
- **The Role of the KM3NeT Telescope**: The future KM3NeT telescope will detect the high - energy neutrino signals of these sources in the 1 - 10 TeV energy range, which will help to further verify these conclusions.
- **The Importance of Theoretical Research**: More theoretical research is needed to directly detect the high - energy cosmic - ray cutoff energy in these sources to provide more stringent constraints.

Through these analyses, the paper provides a new perspective for understanding the sources of high - energy neutrinos and points out the directions for future research.