Outer Space Cyberattacks: Generating Novel Scenarios to Avoid Surprise

Patrick Lin,Keith Abney,Bruce DeBruhl,Kira Abercromby,Henry Danielson,Ryan Jenkins

2024-06-18

Abstract:Though general awareness around it may be low, space cyberattacks are an increasingly urgent problem given the vital role that space systems play in the modern world. Open-source or public discussions about it typically revolve around only a couple generic scenarios, namely satellite hacking and signals jamming or spoofing. But there are so many more possibilities. The report offers a scenario-prompt generator -- a taxonomy of sorts, called the ICARUS matrix -- that can create more than 4 million unique scenario-prompts. We will offer a starting set of 42 scenarios, briefly describing each one, to begin priming the imagination-pump so that many more researchers can bring their diverse expertise and perspectives to bear on the problem. A failure to imagine novel scenarios is a major risk in being taken by surprise and severely harmed by threat actors who are constantly devising new ways, inventive and resourceful ways, to breach the digital systems that control our wired world. To stay vigilant, defenders likewise need to be imaginative to keep up in this adversarial dance between hunter and prey in cybersecurity. More than offering novel scenarios, we will also explore the drivers of the space cybersecurity problem, which include at least seven factors we have identified. For instance, the shared threat of space debris would seem to push rational states and actors to avoid kinetic conflicts in orbit, which weighs in favor of cyberoperations as the dominant form of space conflicts. Outer space is the next frontier for cybersecurity. To guard against space cyberattacks, we need to understand and anticipate them, and imagination is at the very heart of both cybersecurity and frontiers.

Cryptography and Security

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the increasingly urgent security threat posed by cyberattacks in outer space. As the modern world becomes more reliant on space systems, outer space cybersecurity has become a significant concern. However, current public discussions about outer space cyberattacks are usually limited to a few general scenarios, such as satellite hacking and signal jamming or spoofing. This is far from sufficient to deal with the various complex situations that may arise in reality.

To better understand and prevent outer space cyberattacks, the paper proposes a scenario generator called the ICARUS matrix, which can create over 4 million unique scenario prompts. By providing 42 initial scenario descriptions, the paper aims to inspire the imagination of more researchers to propose new scenarios and attract more experts to jointly address this challenge.

Additionally, the paper explores seven factors driving the issue of outer space cybersecurity, including the shared threat of space debris, technological advancements enabling more people to access space, and international political and military competition. These factors collectively contribute to the urgency and complexity of outer space cyberattacks.

In summary, the main goal of this paper is to help the technical community and policymakers better prepare for and respond to potential threats by generating and discussing more novel outer space cyberattack scenarios.