Abstract:Ising machines are effective solvers for complex combinatorial optimization problems. The idea is mapping the optimal solution(s) to a combinatorial optimization problem to the minimum energy state(s) of a physical system, which naturally converges to and stabilizes at a minimum energy state upon perturbance. The underlying mathematical abstraction, the Ising model, was originally developed to explain dynamic behavior of ferromagnetic materials and was shown to generalize to numerous other physical systems. In a generic optimization problem, each variable can interact with another in different ways. At the same time, problem sizes of practical importance are growing very fast. Unfortunately, both the number and connectivity of spins in hardware are subject to fundamental physical limits. Different problems feature different interaction patterns between variables which may not always directly match the network topology supported by a specific Ising machine. In the presence of a mismatch, emulating generic interactions using the machine topology is usually possible, however, comes at the cost of additional physical spins to facilitate the mapping. Furthermore, mismatches in the problem vs. hardware connectivity render even more physical spins necessary. Combinatorial optimization problems of practical importance come with diverse connectivity patterns, which a rigid network topology in hardware cannot efficiently cover. To bridge the gap between application demand and hardware resources, in analogy to classical heterogeneous chip multiprocessors, in this paper we make the case for heterogeneous Ising multiprocessors, where each Ising core features a different connectivity. We provide a detailed design space exploration and quantify the efficiency of different design options in terms of time or energy to solution along with solution accuracy compared to homogeneous alternatives.

A numerical model for time-multiplexed Ising machines based on delay-line oscillators

Highly reconfigurable oscillator-based Ising Machine through quasiperiodic modulation of coupling strength

Oscillator-Network-Based Ising Machine

An Efficient Simulated Oscillator-Based Ising Machine on FPGAs

Parametric Frequency Divider based Ising Machines

Ising Machine Based on Electrically Coupled Spin Hall Nano-Oscillators

A Josephson Parametric Oscillator-Based Ising Machine

All-optical scalable spatial coherent Ising machine

Analog Coupled Oscillator Based Weighted Ising Machine

A CMOS-compatible Ising Machine with Bistable Nodes

A poor man's coherent Ising machine based on opto-electronic feedback systems for solving optimization problems

On Heterogeneous Ising Machines

Ising machines as hardware solvers of combinatorial optimization problems

A Coherent Ising Machine Based On Degenerate Optical Parametric Oscillators

Evaluating spintronics-compatible implementations of Ising machines

A CMOS-compatible oscillation-based VO2 Ising machine solver

A 50-spin surface acoustic wave Ising machine

Time-Division Multiplexing Ising Computer Using Single Stochastic Magnetic Tunneling Junction

Quantitative Evaluation of Hardware Binary Stochastic Neurons

Speed-up coherent Ising machine with a squeezed feedback system