Supporting Changes in Digital Ownership and Data Sovereignty Across the Automotive Value Chain with Catena-X

Marvin Manoury,Theresa Riedelsheimer,Malte Hellmeier,Tom Meyer

2024-06-11

Abstract:Digital Twins have evolved as a concept describing digital representations of physical assets. They can be used to facilitate simulations, monitoring, or optimization of product lifecycles. Considering the concept of a Circular Economy, which entails several lifecycles of, e.g., vehicles, their components, and materials, it is important to investigate how the respective Digital Twins are managed over the lifecycle of their physical assets. This publication presents and compares three approaches for managing Digital Twins in industrial use cases. The analysis considers aspects such as updates, data ownership, and data sovereignty. The results based on the research project Catena-X

Computers and Society,Emerging Technologies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to manage and update Digital Twins (DTs) in the automotive value chain to support changes in data sovereignty and digital ownership. Specifically, the article explores how to ensure that the data of automobiles and their components can be effectively managed, updated, and shared throughout their life cycles while maintaining data ownership and control in the context of the Circular Economy (CE).

### Background of the Problem

With the popularization of the circular economy concept, vehicles and their components need to be reused, remanufactured, refurbished, reused, or recycled at multiple stages in their life cycles. To achieve these goals, continuous updating and management of vehicle and component data are necessary. However, current data management systems have difficulty meeting this need, especially when multiple stakeholders are involved, such as Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs), suppliers, repair shops, and dismantlers.

### Specific Problems of the Research

1. **Data Sovereignty and Ownership**: How to ensure that each stakeholder has control over the data they generate and can access and update this data when needed?
2. **Data Consistency**: How to ensure data consistency and accuracy among different stakeholders, especially in distributed systems?
3. **Lifecycle Management**: How to effectively manage the data of vehicles and their components throughout their entire life cycles, including all stages from production to scrapping?

### Research Methods

The paper addresses the above problems by comparing three different Digital Twin management methods:

1. **One Digital Twin**: All relevant parties share one Digital Twin with read - and - write permissions.
2. **Several Digital Twins**: Each relevant party has its own Digital Twin, which contains specific information.
3. **Several Digital Twins with Licensing and Notification**: Each relevant party has its own Digital Twin and synchronizes updates through a licensing and notification mechanism.

### Conclusions

Through the analysis of these three methods, the paper draws the following conclusions:

- **One Digital Twin**: Although easy to implement, it poses challenges in terms of data sovereignty and ownership because all data is centrally stored in one location.
- **Several Digital Twins**: Supports better data sovereignty, but the information is scattered in multiple places, increasing the complexity of data aggregation.
- **Several Digital Twins with Licensing and Notification**: Combines the advantages of the first two methods, supports data sovereignty, and provides the ability for single - point information retrieval, but requires a complex licensing and notification mechanism.

### Summary

The main contribution of this paper lies in proposing and comparing three different Digital Twin management methods, aiming to solve the key problems of data sovereignty and ownership in the automotive industry. Through these methods, researchers hope to provide theoretical and technical support for future Digital Twin applications, thereby better serving the goals of the circular economy.