The PAU Survey: Photometric Calibration of Narrow Band Images

F. J. Castander,S. Serrano,M. Eriksen,E. Gaztanaga,R. Casas,A. Alarcon,A. H. Bauer,E. Fernandez,D. Navarro-Girones,N. Tonello,L. Cabayol,J. Carretero,J. De Vicente,J. Garcia-Bellido,H. Hildebrandt,H. Hoekstra,B. Joachimi,R. Miquel,C. Padilla,P. Renard,E. Sanchez,I. Sevilla-Noarre,P. Tallada-Crespi

2024-06-11

Abstract:The Physics of the Accelerating Universe (PAU) camera is an optical narrow band and broad band imaging instrument mounted at the prime focus of the William Herschel Telescope. We describe the image calibration procedure of the PAU Survey data. We rely on an external photometric catalogue to calibrate our narrow band data using stars that have been observed by both datasets. We fit stellar templates to the stellar broad band photometry of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey and synthesise narrow band photometry that we compare to the PAUS narrow band data to determine their calibration. Consequently, the PAUS data are in the AB system as inherited from its reference calibrator. We do several tests to check the performance of the calibration. We find it self-consistent when comparing repeated observations of the same objects, with a good overall accuracy to the AB system which we estimate to be at the 2\% precision level and no significant trends as a function of narrow band filter or wavelength. Repeated observations allow us to build a spatial map of the illumination pattern of the system. We also check the wavelength dependence of the calibration comparing to stellar spectra. We find that using only blue stars reduces the effects of variations in the stellar template fitting to broad-band colours, improving the overall precision of the calibration to around 1\% and its wavelength uniformity. The photometric redshift performance obtained with the PAUS data attests to the validity of our calibration to reach the PAUS science goals.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to perform accurate photometric calibration for the narrow - band images of the PAU (Physics of the Accelerating Universe) survey. Specifically, the authors describe the image calibration process of the PAU survey data, aiming to ensure the accuracy and consistency of their data in the AB magnitude system. To achieve this goal, they rely on external photometric catalogs and use stars that are simultaneously observed by these two data sets for calibration.

### Main Problems

1. **Accurate Photometric Calibration**: The PAU camera is installed at the prime focus of the William Herschel telescope to obtain optical narrow - band and wide - band imaging data. Since the narrow - band filter system used by PAU is unique and there are no existing photometric standards that can be directly used to calibrate these data, a new method needs to be developed to ensure the accuracy of its photometric measurements.

2. **Handling Observations under Non - Photometric Conditions**: Most large - scale survey projects need to be able to observe efficiently even under non - photometric conditions. This means that the traditional calibration methods that rely on photometric nights are no longer applicable, and alternative solutions must be found.

3. **Improving Calibration Precision and Wavelength Uniformity**: By observing the same target multiple times and constructing a systematic illumination pattern map, as well as examining the wavelength dependence of the calibration, the authors hope to improve the overall calibration precision to about 1% and ensure its wavelength uniformity.

### Solutions

- **Using SDSS Data as a Reference**: The authors choose to use the wide - band photometric data of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) as a reference. They fit the stellar spectral templates in SDSS to the wide - band photometry and synthesize narrow - band photometry to compare with the narrow - band data of PAUS, thereby determining the zero - point calibration.

- **Improved Stellar Template Matching**: By using only blue stars to reduce the variation effect when fitting the stellar template to the wide - band color, the overall calibration precision is improved.

- **Statistical Cross - Validation**: Statistical cross - validation of the direct calibration of a single exposure is carried out by using the response of spectral - photometric standard stars in the entire PAU filter system.

### Results

Through the above methods, the authors have successfully achieved the photometric calibration of PAUS data and reached a precision level of about 1%. In addition, they have also verified the performance of photometric redshifts obtained based on PAUS data, demonstrating the effectiveness of their calibration method, which can meet the requirements of PAUS scientific goals.

### Formula Summary

The key formulas involved in the calibration process include:

- Relationship between extinction coefficient and air mass:
\[
m_{\text{obs}} - m_0 = k(\lambda)X
\]
where \(m_{\text{obs}}\) is the observed magnitude, \(m_0\) is the magnitude without atmospheric influence, \(k(\lambda)\) is the wavelength - dependent extinction coefficient, and \(X\) is the air mass.

- Calculation of calibrated magnitude:
\[
m_{\text{obs}} = - 2.5\log_{10}f_{\text{obs}}+ZP_1=-2.5\log_{10}f_0 + k(\lambda)X+ZP_2
\]
where \(f_{\text{obs}}\) is the observed flux, \(f_0\) is the flux outside the atmosphere, \(ZP_1\) includes the atmospheric extinction term, and \(ZP_2\) does not include the atmospheric extinction term.

- Synthetic flux calculation:
\[
F(t, R_i, A_v)=\frac{\int f_\lambda t R_i(\lambda)A(\lambda)\lambda^2d\lambda}{c\int R_i(\lambda)d\lambda}
\]
where \(f_\lambda\) is the wavelength flux density, \(t\) represents the stellar template, \(R_i\) is the transmittance of the reference filter, and \(A_v\) is the normalization factor applied to the O’Donnell extinction law.

Through these methods and techniques, the authors ensure the high quality and reliability of the PAU survey data.