Abstract:Introduction: Structural neuroimaging analyses require 'research quality' images, acquired with costly MRI acquisitions. Isotropic (3D) T1 images are desirable for quantitative analyses, however a routine compromise in the clinical setting is to acquire anisotropic (2D) analogues for qualitative visual inspection. Machine learning-based software have shown promise in addressing some of the limitations of 2D scans in research applications, yet their efficacy in quantitative research is not well understood. To evaluate the applicability of image preprocessing methods, morphometry in idiopathic generalised epilepsy (IGE)--in which, pathology-related abnormalities of the subcortical structures have been reproducibly demonstrated--was investigated first in 3D scans, then in 2D scans, resampled images, and synthesised images. Methods: 2D and 3D T1 MRI were acquired during the same scanning session from 31 individuals (males = 14, mean age = 32.16) undergoing evaluation for IGE at the Walton Centre NHS Foundation Trust, Liverpool, as well as 39 healthy age- and sex-matched controls (males = 16, mean age = 32.13). The DL+DiReCT pipeline was used to provide segmentations of the 2D images, and estimates of regional volume and thickness. The 2D scans were also resampled into isotropic images using NiBabel, and preprocessed into synthetic isotropic images using SynthSR. For the 3D scans, untransformed 2D scans, resampled images, and synthesised images, FreeSurfer 7.2.0 was used to create parcellations of 178 anatomical regions (equivalent to the 178 parcellations provided as part of the DL+DiReCT pipeline), defined by the aseg and Destrieux atlases, and FSL FIRST was used to segment subcortical surface shapes. Spatial correspondence and intraclass correlations between the morphometrics of the five parcellations were first determined, then subcortical surface shape abnormalities associated with IGE were identified by comparing the FSL FIRST outputs of patients with controls. Results: When standardised to the metrics derived from the 3D scans, cortical volume and thickness estimates trended lower for the untransformed 2D, DL+DiReCT, resampled, and SynthSR images, whereas subcortical volume estimates did not differ. Dice coefficients revealed a low spatial similarity between the cortices of the 3D scans and the other images overall, which was higher in the subcortical structures. Intraclass correlation coefficients reiterated this disparity, with estimates of thickness being less similar than those of volume, and DL+DiReCT estimates trending less similar than the other images types. For the people with epilepsy, the 3D scans showed significant surface deflations across various subcortical structures when compared to healthy controls. Analysis of the untransformed 2D scans enabled the detection of a subset of subcortical abnormalities, whereas analyses of the resampled and synthetic images attenuated almost all significance. Conclusions: Generalised image synthesis methods do not currently attenuate partial volume effects resulting from low through plane resolution in anisotropic MRI scans, instead quantitative analyses using 2D images should be interpreted with caution, and researchers should consider the potential implications of preprocessing. Keywords: epilepsy, quantitative MRI, deep-learning, image synthesis, morphometry, shape analysis

The Imaging Database for Epilepsy And Surgery (IDEAS)

Linking Mri Postprocessing with Magnetic Source Imaging in Mri-Negative Epilepsy

Neuroimaging characteristics of MRI-negative orbitofrontal epilepsy with focus on voxel-based morphometric MRI postprocessing.

Application of MRI Post-processing in Presurgical Evaluation of Non-lesional Cingulate Epilepsy.

Interpretable Surface-Based Detection of Focal Cortical Dysplasias: a Multi-centre Epilepsy Lesion Detection Study

ReMIND: The Brain Resection Multimodal Imaging Database

Complementary structural and functional abnormalities to localise epileptogenic tissue

Multimodal noninvasive evaluation in MRI-negative operculoinsular epilepsy.

Yield of MRI, high-density electric source imaging (HD-ESI), SPECT and PET in epilepsy surgery candidates

Deep learning-based automated segmentation of resection cavities on postsurgical epilepsy MRI

Seizure freedom after surgical resection of diffusion-weighted MRI abnormalities

Multimodal and quantitative analysis of the epileptogenic zone network in the pre-surgical evaluation of drug-resistant focal epilepsy

Machine Learning-Based Reconstruction of 2D MRI for Quantitative Morphometry in Epilepsy

Clinical added value of interictal automated electrical source imaging in the presurgical evaluation of MRI-negative epilepsy: A real-life experience in 29 consecutive patients

Mapping Epileptic Networks Using Simultaneous Intracranial EEG-fMRI

IntrAnat Electrodes: A Free Database and Visualization Software for Intracranial Electroencephalographic Data Processed for Case and Group Studies

Electromagnetic Source Imaging in Presurgical Evaluation of Children with Drug-Resistant Epilepsy

Integrating standard epilepsy protocol, ASL-perfusion, MP2RAGE/EDGE and the MELD-FCD classifier in the detection of subtle epileptogenic lesions: a 3 Tesla MRI pilot study

Incorporation of quantitative MRI in a model to predict temporal lobe epilepsy surgery outcome

Combining OPM and lesion mapping data for epilepsy surgery planning: a simulation study